Perdarahan Gastrointestinal
Published on September 11, 2026
Risk Factors
NSAIDs or aspirin use, H. pylori infection, alcohol abuse, liver cirrhosis with portal hypertension, anticoagulant/antiplatelet therapy, prior GI bleeding, advanced age, coagulopathy, chronic kidney disease
Etiology
Upper GI bleeding (UGIB): Peptic ulcer disease (most common), esophageal/gastric varices, Mallory-Weiss tear, erosive gastritis/esophagitis, Dieulafoy lesion, aortoenteric fistula. Lower GI bleeding (LGIB): Diverticulosis (most common), angiodysplasia, colorectal neoplasm, hemorrhoids, ischemic colitis, inflammatory bowel disease
Presentation
Hematemesis or coffee-ground emesis (UGIB), melena (UGIB or proximal LGIB), hematochezia (LGIB, or brisk UGIB), orthostatic symptoms, fatigue, syncope, abdominal pain (variable)
Classic Exam
Tachycardia, hypotension, orthostatic changes, pallor, abdominal tenderness (if ulcer perforation), stigmata of chronic liver disease (spider angiomata, caput medusae, jaundice) in variceal bleeding, rectal exam with gross blood or melena
Diagnostics
Elevated BUN-to-creatinine ratio > 20:1 suggests UGIB, nasogastric aspirate with blood or coffee grounds, decreased hemoglobin/hematocrit (may lag), upper endoscopy (EGD) is the gold standard for UGIB, colonoscopy is the gold standard for LGIB
Management
IV fluid resuscitation and transfusion (target hemoglobin 7 g/dL), IV proton pump inhibitor (PPI) for nonvariceal UGIB, octreotide + antibiotics + urgent endoscopy for variceal UGIB, endoscopic intervention (clipping, cautery, banding), surgery or interventional radiology for refractory bleeding
01Pathophysiology
Gastrointestinal (GI) bleeding is divided anatomically by the ligament of Treitz (the suspensory ligament of the duodenum at the duodenojejunal junction). Bleeding proximal to this landmark is classified as upper GI bleeding (UGIB), and bleeding distal to it is classified as lower GI bleeding (LGIB). This distinction is not arbitrary; it dictates the diagnostic approach, the initial test of choice, and the management pathway.
In peptic ulcer disease, the most common cause of UGIB, disruption of the gastric or duodenal mucosa by acid and pepsin erodes into the submucosal vasculature. Posterior duodenal ulcers are particularly dangerous because they can erode into the gastroduodenal artery, producing brisk arterial hemorrhage. Gastric ulcers along the lesser curvature can erode into the left gastric artery. The mechanism is straightforward: mucosal defense (bicarbonate secretion, prostaglandin-mediated blood flow, mucus barrier) is overwhelmed by aggressive factors (acid, NSAIDs, H. pylori). NSAIDs inhibit cyclooxygenase (COX), reducing prostaglandin synthesis and thereby weakening the mucosal barrier. H. pylori directly damages epithelial cells and provokes chronic inflammation.
In variceal bleeding, the pathophysiology begins with portal hypertension, most commonly from liver cirrhosis. As hepatic architecture is distorted by fibrosis, resistance to portal blood flow increases. Portal pressures above 12 mmHg (measured by the hepatic venous pressure gradient, or HVPG) place the patient at risk for variceal hemorrhage. Blood is shunted through portosystemic collaterals, including the left gastric (coronary) vein, which feeds esophageal submucosal venous plexuses. These thin-walled, dilated veins rupture under high pressure, producing sudden, voluminous hematemesis. This is why variceal bleeding tends to be dramatic and immediately life-threatening.
A Mallory-Weiss tear results from a longitudinal mucosal laceration at the gastroesophageal (GE) junction, typically caused by forceful or prolonged retching and vomiting. The mechanism is sudden increases in intra-abdominal pressure transmitted to the GE junction. The tear involves the mucosa and submucosa but does not penetrate the full thickness of the wall (which would instead be a Boerhaave syndrome, a transmural esophageal rupture, a critical distinction on exams).
For lower GI bleeding, diverticulosis is the most common cause of significant hematochezia in older adults. Diverticula form at points where the vasa recta (nutrient arteries) penetrate the colonic wall. Over time, the artery at the dome of the diverticulum becomes exposed and can rupture, producing painless, large-volume bright red or maroon rectal bleeding. This is arterial bleeding, which is why it can be brisk despite originating from a small structural lesion.
Angiodysplasia (arteriovenous malformations) is the second most common cause of LGIB in the elderly. These are degenerative, dilated, thin-walled vascular structures in the submucosa, most often found in the right colon (cecum and ascending colon). The mechanism involves chronic, low-grade venous obstruction of submucosal veins as they pass through the muscular layer, leading to progressive dilation and eventual formation of arteriovenous communications. There is a known association between angiodysplasia and aortic stenosis (Heyde syndrome), where acquired von Willebrand factor deficiency from shear stress across a stenotic valve contributes to bleeding.
The reason melena (black, tarry, foul-smelling stool) is characteristic of UGIB is that blood is exposed to gastric acid and intestinal bacteria during transit, converting hemoglobin to hematin and other oxidized pigments. As little as 50 to 100 mL of blood in the upper tract can produce melena. Hematochezia (bright red blood per rectum) usually indicates a lower GI source, but in the setting of hemodynamic instability, it can also indicate a brisk upper GI source where transit is too rapid for oxidation to occur. This is a commonly tested concept.
02Classification and Clinical Manifestation
Upper GI Bleeding (Proximal to Ligament of Treitz)
COMMON CAUSES
Peptic ulcer disease, esophageal varices, gastric varices, Mallory-Weiss tear, erosive gastritis/esophagitis, Dieulafoy lesion, aortoenteric fistula
TYPICAL PRESENTATION
Hematemesis (bright red or coffee-ground), melena, possible hematochezia if brisk
KEY FEATURES
BUN/Cr ratio > 20:1, nasogastric lavage may show blood
Lower GI Bleeding (Distal to Ligament of Treitz)
COMMON CAUSES
Diverticulosis, angiodysplasia, colorectal cancer/polyps, hemorrhoids, ischemic colitis, IBD, infectious colitis
TYPICAL PRESENTATION
Hematochezia (bright red or maroon stool), rarely melena if right-sided source
KEY FEATURES
Usually painless (diverticulosis, angiodysplasia); painful if ischemic colitis or IBD
Obscure GI Bleeding
COMMON CAUSES
Small bowel angiodysplasia, Meckel diverticulum, small bowel tumors, Dieulafoy lesion
TYPICAL PRESENTATION
Recurrent or persistent bleeding with negative EGD and colonoscopy
KEY FEATURES
Requires capsule endoscopy or deep enteroscopy for diagnosis
Occult GI Bleeding
COMMON CAUSES
Colorectal neoplasm, gastric cancer, Cameron lesions (hiatal hernia erosions), angiodysplasia
TYPICAL PRESENTATION
Iron deficiency anemia without visible blood loss, positive fecal occult blood test
KEY FEATURES
No overt bleeding; detected through anemia workup or screening
CLASSIFICATION | COMMON CAUSES | TYPICAL PRESENTATION | KEY FEATURES |
|---|---|---|---|
Upper GI Bleeding (Proximal to Ligament of Treitz) | Peptic ulcer disease, esophageal varices, gastric varices, Mallory-Weiss tear, erosive gastritis/esophagitis, Dieulafoy lesion, aortoenteric fistula | Hematemesis (bright red or coffee-ground), melena, possible hematochezia if brisk | BUN/Cr ratio > 20:1, nasogastric lavage may show blood |
Lower GI Bleeding (Distal to Ligament of Treitz) | Diverticulosis, angiodysplasia, colorectal cancer/polyps, hemorrhoids, ischemic colitis, IBD, infectious colitis | Hematochezia (bright red or maroon stool), rarely melena if right-sided source | Usually painless (diverticulosis, angiodysplasia); painful if ischemic colitis or IBD |
Obscure GI Bleeding | Small bowel angiodysplasia, Meckel diverticulum, small bowel tumors, Dieulafoy lesion | Recurrent or persistent bleeding with negative EGD and colonoscopy | Requires capsule endoscopy or deep enteroscopy for diagnosis |
Occult GI Bleeding | Colorectal neoplasm, gastric cancer, Cameron lesions (hiatal hernia erosions), angiodysplasia | Iron deficiency anemia without visible blood loss, positive fecal occult blood test | No overt bleeding; detected through anemia workup or screening |
SEVERITY | CLINICAL INDICATORS |
|---|---|
Mild | Hemodynamically stable, heart rate < 100, systolic BP > 100 mmHg, hemoglobin > 10 g/dL |
Moderate | Tachycardia (HR 100 to 120), mild orthostatic changes, hemoglobin 7 to 10 g/dL |
Severe | Hypotension (SBP < 90), marked tachycardia (HR > 120), hemoglobin < 7 g/dL, altered mental status, signs of shock |
Ia
DESCRIPTION
Spurting arterial hemorrhage
REBLEEDING RISK
High (> 90%)
Ib
DESCRIPTION
Oozing hemorrhage
REBLEEDING RISK
High (50 to 80%)
IIa
DESCRIPTION
Visible vessel (non-bleeding)
REBLEEDING RISK
Moderate (40 to 50%)
IIb
DESCRIPTION
Adherent clot
REBLEEDING RISK
Moderate (20 to 30%)
IIc
DESCRIPTION
Flat pigmented spot
REBLEEDING RISK
Low (< 10%)
III
DESCRIPTION
Clean-base ulcer
REBLEEDING RISK
Very low (< 5%)
ENDOSCOPIC CLASSIFICATION (FORREST) FOR PEPTIC ULCER BLEEDING | DESCRIPTION | REBLEEDING RISK |
|---|---|---|
Ia | Spurting arterial hemorrhage | High (> 90%) |
Ib | Oozing hemorrhage | High (50 to 80%) |
IIa | Visible vessel (non-bleeding) | Moderate (40 to 50%) |
IIb | Adherent clot | Moderate (20 to 30%) |
IIc | Flat pigmented spot | Low (< 10%) |
III | Clean-base ulcer | Very low (< 5%) |
The Forrest classification is clinically important because it determines whether endoscopic therapy is indicated. Forrest Ia, Ib, and IIa lesions require endoscopic intervention (such as thermal coagulation, hemoclipping, or injection therapy). Forrest IIb (adherent clot) is controversial, but current guidelines favor removing the clot and treating the underlying lesion. Forrest IIc and III do not require endoscopic therapy and can be managed medically with PPI alone.
03Diagnostic Workup
Complete blood count (CBC)
PURPOSE
Assess hemoglobin/hematocrit to quantify blood loss
WHEN TO ORDER
Immediately on presentation; serial monitoring
BUN and Creatinine
PURPOSE
BUN/Cr ratio > 20:1 suggests UGIB (digested blood increases urea absorption)
WHEN TO ORDER
Part of initial labs
Coagulation studies (PT/INR, PTT)
PURPOSE
Identify coagulopathy, assess anticoagulant effect
WHEN TO ORDER
All patients, especially those on warfarin or with liver disease
Type and crossmatch
PURPOSE
Prepare for possible transfusion
WHEN TO ORDER
All patients with significant bleeding
Nasogastric (NG) aspirate/lavage
PURPOSE
Bloody or coffee-ground aspirate suggests UGIB; clear non-bilious aspirate is nondiagnostic
WHEN TO ORDER
When the source (upper vs lower) is unclear
Upper endoscopy (EGD)
PURPOSE
Gold standard for UGIB; both diagnostic and therapeutic
WHEN TO ORDER
Within 24 hours for most UGIB; within 12 hours if variceal bleeding suspected
Colonoscopy
PURPOSE
Gold standard for LGIB; diagnostic and therapeutic
WHEN TO ORDER
After adequate bowel preparation, typically within 24 hours of stabilization
CT angiography (CTA)
PURPOSE
Detects active bleeding at rates 0.3 to 0.5 mL/min
WHEN TO ORDER
When bleeding is too brisk for colonoscopy or endoscopy is nondiagnostic
Tagged RBC scan (nuclear scintigraphy)
PURPOSE
Detects bleeding at rates as low as 0.1 mL/min; localizes but does not treat
WHEN TO ORDER
Intermittent or slow bleeding not localized by other methods
Angiography (mesenteric)
PURPOSE
Detects bleeding at rates 0.5 to 1.0 mL/min; allows embolization
WHEN TO ORDER
After positive CTA or failed endoscopic hemostasis
Capsule endoscopy
PURPOSE
Visualizes small bowel mucosa
WHEN TO ORDER
Obscure GI bleeding after negative EGD and colonoscopy
Meckel scan (Tc-99m pertechnetate)
PURPOSE
Detects ectopic gastric mucosa in a Meckel diverticulum
WHEN TO ORDER
Young patient with unexplained rectal bleeding
TEST | PURPOSE | WHEN TO ORDER |
|---|---|---|
Complete blood count (CBC) | Assess hemoglobin/hematocrit to quantify blood loss | Immediately on presentation; serial monitoring |
BUN and Creatinine | BUN/Cr ratio > 20:1 suggests UGIB (digested blood increases urea absorption) | Part of initial labs |
Coagulation studies (PT/INR, PTT) | Identify coagulopathy, assess anticoagulant effect | All patients, especially those on warfarin or with liver disease |
Type and crossmatch | Prepare for possible transfusion | All patients with significant bleeding |
Nasogastric (NG) aspirate/lavage | Bloody or coffee-ground aspirate suggests UGIB; clear non-bilious aspirate is nondiagnostic | When the source (upper vs lower) is unclear |
Upper endoscopy (EGD) | Gold standard for UGIB; both diagnostic and therapeutic | Within 24 hours for most UGIB; within 12 hours if variceal bleeding suspected |
Colonoscopy | Gold standard for LGIB; diagnostic and therapeutic | After adequate bowel preparation, typically within 24 hours of stabilization |
CT angiography (CTA) | Detects active bleeding at rates 0.3 to 0.5 mL/min | When bleeding is too brisk for colonoscopy or endoscopy is nondiagnostic |
Tagged RBC scan (nuclear scintigraphy) | Detects bleeding at rates as low as 0.1 mL/min; localizes but does not treat | Intermittent or slow bleeding not localized by other methods |
Angiography (mesenteric) | Detects bleeding at rates 0.5 to 1.0 mL/min; allows embolization | After positive CTA or failed endoscopic hemostasis |
Capsule endoscopy | Visualizes small bowel mucosa | Obscure GI bleeding after negative EGD and colonoscopy |
Meckel scan (Tc-99m pertechnetate) | Detects ectopic gastric mucosa in a Meckel diverticulum | Young patient with unexplained rectal bleeding |
The Best Initial Test for any patient presenting with GI bleeding is clinical assessment and resuscitation, combined with basic laboratory studies (CBC, BUN/Cr, coagulation panel, type and crossmatch). These do not tell you the source, but they establish the severity and guide transfusion decisions.
An important nuance: hemoglobin and hematocrit may be normal early in acute bleeding because blood loss is whole blood (both red cells and plasma are lost proportionally). It takes 24 to 72 hours for equilibration with extravascular fluid to reveal the true drop. Serial measurements are therefore essential. This is a commonly tested concept: do not be falsely reassured by a normal initial hemoglobin in an acutely bleeding patient.
A BUN/Cr ratio greater than 20:1 is a useful clue pointing toward an upper GI source. Blood in the upper tract is digested like a protein meal; amino acids are absorbed in the small intestine and converted to urea in the liver, raising the BUN disproportionately to creatinine. This is a soft sign, not a definitive test, but it frequently appears in vignettes as a discriminating detail.
Nasogastric aspirate can be helpful when the source is uncertain. A bloody or coffee-ground aspirate confirms an upper source. However, a clear, non-bilious aspirate does not rule out UGIB because a duodenal source may not reflux into the stomach, especially if the pylorus is closed. A clear, bilious aspirate makes an upper source much less likely.
For confirmed or suspected UGIB, upper endoscopy (EGD) is both the best initial diagnostic test and the gold standard. It should be performed within 24 hours of presentation. In patients with suspected variceal bleeding or hemodynamic instability despite resuscitation, endoscopy should be performed within 12 hours or even more urgently. EGD allows direct visualization, biopsy, and therapeutic intervention in the same session.
For LGIB, colonoscopy is the best initial diagnostic and therapeutic test. The patient typically requires bowel preparation first, and colonoscopy is ideally performed within 24 hours. In patients with hemodynamically significant LGIB where colonoscopy is not feasible (too brisk, patient too unstable), CT angiography is the next step. CTA can localize the bleeding site and guide subsequent angiographic embolization.
Tagged RBC scan is the most sensitive noninvasive test for detecting GI bleeding. It can identify bleeding at very low rates (0.1 mL/min). However, it has poor anatomic localization, so it is most useful for confirming that active bleeding is occurring and roughly localizing it before angiography.
Mesenteric angiography requires a higher bleeding rate to be diagnostic ( 0.5 mL/min), but it offers the advantage of therapeutic embolization. It is typically reserved for patients who are bleeding too briskly for colonoscopy or who have failed endoscopic therapy.
04Management and Treatment
Initial resuscitation (all GI bleeding)
MANAGEMENT
Two large-bore IVs (18-gauge or larger), IV crystalloid, type and crossmatch, transfuse pRBCs
KEY DETAILS
Target hemoglobin 7 g/dL (restrictive strategy); threshold of 8 to 9 g/dL for patients with cardiovascular disease
Nonvariceal UGIB (e.g., peptic ulcer)
MANAGEMENT
IV PPI (pantoprazole 80 mg bolus, then 8 mg/hr continuous infusion for 72 hours), followed by oral PPI
KEY DETAILS
Endoscopic therapy for Forrest Ia, Ib, IIa lesions; H. pylori test-and-treat
Variceal UGIB
MANAGEMENT
Octreotide (50 mcg IV bolus, then 50 mcg/hr infusion for 3 to 5 days) + IV ceftriaxone (1 g daily for 7 days) + urgent endoscopic variceal ligation (EVL/banding)
KEY DETAILS
Antibiotics reduce rebleeding and mortality in cirrhotic patients; if EVL fails, consider TIPS (transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt)
Variceal bleeding: balloon tamponade
MANAGEMENT
Sengstaken-Blakemore tube or Minnesota tube
KEY DETAILS
Bridge to definitive therapy; used only when endoscopy is unavailable or fails and patient is actively exsanguinating; maximum 24 hours
Variceal prophylaxis (primary)
MANAGEMENT
Nonselective beta-blocker (propranolol or nadolol, titrate to resting HR 55 to 60) or EVL
KEY DETAILS
For patients with medium or large varices on screening endoscopy
Variceal prophylaxis (secondary)
MANAGEMENT
Combination of nonselective beta-blocker + EVL
KEY DETAILS
After a first variceal bleed; TIPS if refractory
LGIB: Diverticular bleeding
MANAGEMENT
Most episodes (70 to 80%) stop spontaneously; colonoscopy with endoscopic therapy (clipping, cautery) for active or stigmata of recent bleeding
KEY DETAILS
If rebleeding or failure to stop: angiographic embolization or segmental colectomy
LGIB: Angiodysplasia
MANAGEMENT
Endoscopic argon plasma coagulation (APC) or thermal coagulation
KEY DETAILS
Evaluate for aortic stenosis (Heyde syndrome)
Anticoagulant/antiplatelet management
MANAGEMENT
Reverse anticoagulation if bleeding is life-threatening (vitamin K, FFP, PCC for warfarin; idarucizumab for dabigatran; andexanet alfa for factor Xa inhibitors)
KEY DETAILS
Weigh thrombotic risk vs bleeding risk; consult cardiology if patient has recent coronary stent
Refractory or uncontrolled bleeding
MANAGEMENT
Interventional radiology for embolization; surgery (oversewing ulcer, segmental colectomy) as last resort
KEY DETAILS
Surgery is reserved for failure of all endoscopic and radiologic interventions
CLINICAL SCENARIO | MANAGEMENT | KEY DETAILS |
|---|---|---|
Initial resuscitation (all GI bleeding) | Two large-bore IVs (18-gauge or larger), IV crystalloid, type and crossmatch, transfuse pRBCs | Target hemoglobin 7 g/dL (restrictive strategy); threshold of 8 to 9 g/dL for patients with cardiovascular disease |
Nonvariceal UGIB (e.g., peptic ulcer) | IV PPI (pantoprazole 80 mg bolus, then 8 mg/hr continuous infusion for 72 hours), followed by oral PPI | Endoscopic therapy for Forrest Ia, Ib, IIa lesions; H. pylori test-and-treat |
Variceal UGIB | Octreotide (50 mcg IV bolus, then 50 mcg/hr infusion for 3 to 5 days) + IV ceftriaxone (1 g daily for 7 days) + urgent endoscopic variceal ligation (EVL/banding) | Antibiotics reduce rebleeding and mortality in cirrhotic patients; if EVL fails, consider TIPS (transjugular intrahepatic portosystemic shunt) |
Variceal bleeding: balloon tamponade | Sengstaken-Blakemore tube or Minnesota tube | Bridge to definitive therapy; used only when endoscopy is unavailable or fails and patient is actively exsanguinating; maximum 24 hours |
Variceal prophylaxis (primary) | Nonselective beta-blocker (propranolol or nadolol, titrate to resting HR 55 to 60) or EVL | For patients with medium or large varices on screening endoscopy |
Variceal prophylaxis (secondary) | Combination of nonselective beta-blocker + EVL | After a first variceal bleed; TIPS if refractory |
LGIB: Diverticular bleeding | Most episodes (70 to 80%) stop spontaneously; colonoscopy with endoscopic therapy (clipping, cautery) for active or stigmata of recent bleeding | If rebleeding or failure to stop: angiographic embolization or segmental colectomy |
LGIB: Angiodysplasia | Endoscopic argon plasma coagulation (APC) or thermal coagulation | Evaluate for aortic stenosis (Heyde syndrome) |
Anticoagulant/antiplatelet management | Reverse anticoagulation if bleeding is life-threatening (vitamin K, FFP, PCC for warfarin; idarucizumab for dabigatran; andexanet alfa for factor Xa inhibitors) | Weigh thrombotic risk vs bleeding risk; consult cardiology if patient has recent coronary stent |
Refractory or uncontrolled bleeding | Interventional radiology for embolization; surgery (oversewing ulcer, segmental colectomy) as last resort | Surgery is reserved for failure of all endoscopic and radiologic interventions |
Acute stabilization follows the ABCs. Two large-bore peripheral IVs (18-gauge or larger) should be placed immediately. Volume resuscitation with isotonic crystalloid is initiated while blood products are being prepared. The current evidence supports a restrictive transfusion strategy with a target hemoglobin of 7 g/dL in hemodynamically stable patients. Over-transfusion in variceal bleeding is particularly harmful because it can raise portal pressures and worsen hemorrhage. In patients with active coronary disease, the transfusion threshold is generally higher (8 to 9 g/dL).
For nonvariceal UGIB, intravenous PPI therapy is the cornerstone. Pantoprazole 80 mg IV bolus followed by 8 mg/hr continuous infusion for 72 hours is the standard regimen. The rationale is that clot stability over an ulcer bed requires a gastric pH above 6; continuous high-dose PPI achieves this. After 72 hours, the patient is transitioned to oral PPI (pantoprazole 40 mg twice daily, then once daily). All patients with peptic ulcer disease should be tested for H. pylori and treated if positive (triple therapy: PPI + clarithromycin 500 mg twice daily + amoxicillin 1 g twice daily for 14 days, or a bismuth quadruple regimen). NSAIDs must be discontinued.
For variceal UGIB, three interventions are started simultaneously before endoscopy: (1) octreotide (a somatostatin analog that reduces splanchnic blood flow and portal pressure), given as a 50 mcg IV bolus followed by 50 mcg/hr infusion for 3 to 5 days; (2) prophylactic antibiotics (ceftriaxone 1 g IV daily for 7 days), which have been shown to reduce bacterial translocation, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, rebleeding, and mortality; (3) urgent endoscopy with endoscopic variceal ligation (banding), which is preferred over sclerotherapy. If banding fails to control hemorrhage, a TIPS procedure is the next step. Balloon tamponade (Sengstaken-Blakemore or Minnesota tube) is a temporizing bridge measure, not definitive therapy, and carries risks of esophageal necrosis and aspiration.
Primary prophylaxis of variceal bleeding is indicated in cirrhotic patients found to have medium or large varices on screening endoscopy. Options include nonselective beta-blockers (propranolol or nadolol, titrated to a resting heart rate of 55 to 60 bpm) or endoscopic variceal ligation. Cardioselective beta-blockers (such as metoprolol) are not effective for this purpose because they do not block the beta-2 receptors responsible for splanchnic vasoconstriction. Secondary prophylaxis (after a first variceal bleed) uses the combination of a nonselective beta-blocker plus EVL.
For lower GI bleeding, most diverticular hemorrhages resolve spontaneously without intervention. For persistent or recurrent bleeding, colonoscopy with endoscopic therapy (hemoclipping, thermal coagulation, epinephrine injection) is the first-line approach. If colonoscopy fails or bleeding is too brisk, angiographic embolization via interventional radiology is pursued. Surgery (segmental colectomy) is reserved for patients who fail all other measures.
05Differential Diagnosis and Distractors
Peptic ulcer disease vs. Gastric cancer
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both can cause UGIB with hematemesis and epigastric pain
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Ulcer is more common, often NSAID or H. pylori related; cancer suggested by weight loss, early satiety, age > 55, non-healing ulcer on biopsy, irregular ulcer margins on endoscopy
Esophageal varices vs. Mallory-Weiss tear
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause hematemesis
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Varices present with large-volume hematemesis in a patient with stigmata of liver disease (ascites, jaundice, spider angiomata); Mallory-Weiss presents with hematemesis following forceful retching/vomiting, often in an alcoholic or bulimic patient
Mallory-Weiss tear vs. Boerhaave syndrome
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both occur after forceful vomiting
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Mallory-Weiss is a mucosal tear causing hematemesis; Boerhaave is a transmural esophageal rupture causing severe chest pain, subcutaneous emphysema, and mediastinitis (Mackler triad: vomiting, chest pain, subcutaneous emphysema). Boerhaave has no hematemesis.
Diverticulosis vs. Colorectal cancer
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause hematochezia in older adults
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Diverticular bleeding is sudden, painless, and typically self-limited with large-volume bright red blood; colorectal cancer presents with chronic, low-volume bleeding, iron deficiency anemia, weight loss, and change in bowel habits
Diverticulosis vs. Angiodysplasia
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause painless lower GI bleeding in the elderly
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Diverticular bleeding is more commonly left-sided (sigmoid) and tends to be a single brisk episode; angiodysplasia is more commonly right-sided (cecum/ascending colon) and tends to present with chronic, intermittent, low-grade bleeding
Ischemic colitis vs. Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD)
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause bloody diarrhea with abdominal pain
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Ischemic colitis affects an older patient, often after hypotension or vascular surgery, involves the "watershed" areas (splenic flexure, rectosigmoid junction); IBD affects younger patients with chronic/relapsing course, extraintestinal manifestations
Upper GI bleed presenting with hematochezia vs. Lower GI bleed
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both present with bright red blood per rectum
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
A brisk UGIB can cause hematochezia; the key is hemodynamic instability (tachycardia, hypotension) with hematochezia. Always consider UGIB when a patient with hematochezia is hemodynamically unstable; place an NG tube or perform EGD before assuming a lower source
Hemorrhoids vs. Colorectal cancer
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause rectal bleeding
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Hemorrhoids produce painless, bright red blood on the toilet paper or dripping into the bowl, in a younger patient; cancer causes mixed-in blood with stool, change in stool caliber, weight loss, anemia. Any patient over 40 to 45 with new rectal bleeding should be evaluated with colonoscopy
Meckel diverticulum vs. Intussusception (pediatric)
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause rectal bleeding in children
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Meckel presents with painless, brick-red or maroon rectal bleeding in a child under 2 years; intussusception presents with colicky abdominal pain, "currant jelly" stool, and a palpable sausage-shaped abdominal mass
Aortoenteric fistula vs. Peptic ulcer disease
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Both cause UGIB with hematemesis
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Aortoenteric fistula should be suspected in any patient with a history of aortic graft surgery who presents with GI bleeding. There is often a "herald bleed" (small self-limited bleed) followed by catastrophic hemorrhage. This is a surgical emergency.
DIFFERENTIAL | WHY IT IS SIMILAR | KEY DISCRIMINATOR |
|---|---|---|
Peptic ulcer disease vs. Gastric cancer | Both can cause UGIB with hematemesis and epigastric pain | Ulcer is more common, often NSAID or H. pylori related; cancer suggested by weight loss, early satiety, age > 55, non-healing ulcer on biopsy, irregular ulcer margins on endoscopy |
Esophageal varices vs. Mallory-Weiss tear | Both cause hematemesis | Varices present with large-volume hematemesis in a patient with stigmata of liver disease (ascites, jaundice, spider angiomata); Mallory-Weiss presents with hematemesis following forceful retching/vomiting, often in an alcoholic or bulimic patient |
Mallory-Weiss tear vs. Boerhaave syndrome | Both occur after forceful vomiting | Mallory-Weiss is a mucosal tear causing hematemesis; Boerhaave is a transmural esophageal rupture causing severe chest pain, subcutaneous emphysema, and mediastinitis (Mackler triad: vomiting, chest pain, subcutaneous emphysema). Boerhaave has no hematemesis. |
Diverticulosis vs. Colorectal cancer | Both cause hematochezia in older adults | Diverticular bleeding is sudden, painless, and typically self-limited with large-volume bright red blood; colorectal cancer presents with chronic, low-volume bleeding, iron deficiency anemia, weight loss, and change in bowel habits |
Diverticulosis vs. Angiodysplasia | Both cause painless lower GI bleeding in the elderly | Diverticular bleeding is more commonly left-sided (sigmoid) and tends to be a single brisk episode; angiodysplasia is more commonly right-sided (cecum/ascending colon) and tends to present with chronic, intermittent, low-grade bleeding |
Ischemic colitis vs. Inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) | Both cause bloody diarrhea with abdominal pain | Ischemic colitis affects an older patient, often after hypotension or vascular surgery, involves the "watershed" areas (splenic flexure, rectosigmoid junction); IBD affects younger patients with chronic/relapsing course, extraintestinal manifestations |
Upper GI bleed presenting with hematochezia vs. Lower GI bleed | Both present with bright red blood per rectum | A brisk UGIB can cause hematochezia; the key is hemodynamic instability (tachycardia, hypotension) with hematochezia. Always consider UGIB when a patient with hematochezia is hemodynamically unstable; place an NG tube or perform EGD before assuming a lower source |
Hemorrhoids vs. Colorectal cancer | Both cause rectal bleeding | Hemorrhoids produce painless, bright red blood on the toilet paper or dripping into the bowl, in a younger patient; cancer causes mixed-in blood with stool, change in stool caliber, weight loss, anemia. Any patient over 40 to 45 with new rectal bleeding should be evaluated with colonoscopy |
Meckel diverticulum vs. Intussusception (pediatric) | Both cause rectal bleeding in children | Meckel presents with painless, brick-red or maroon rectal bleeding in a child under 2 years; intussusception presents with colicky abdominal pain, "currant jelly" stool, and a palpable sausage-shaped abdominal mass |
Aortoenteric fistula vs. Peptic ulcer disease | Both cause UGIB with hematemesis | Aortoenteric fistula should be suspected in any patient with a history of aortic graft surgery who presents with GI bleeding. There is often a "herald bleed" (small self-limited bleed) followed by catastrophic hemorrhage. This is a surgical emergency. |
06Traps and High-Yield Pearls
The most common way students get questions on GI bleeding wrong is by failing to consider an upper GI source in a patient presenting with hematochezia. Exam vignettes will describe a hemodynamically unstable patient with bright red blood per rectum, and the student reflexively selects colonoscopy. The correct answer is to evaluate the upper tract first (EGD or at minimum NG aspirate) because a brisk upper source can easily present with hematochezia. The rule to remember: hemodynamic instability plus hematochezia should trigger evaluation for UGIB before assuming a lower source.
Another frequently tested trap is the initial hemoglobin. Students see a normal hemoglobin in an acutely bleeding patient and conclude the bleeding is not significant. Early hemoglobin is unreliable because acute whole blood loss does not immediately change the concentration; hemodilution has not yet occurred. Serial hemoglobin measurements and clinical signs (tachycardia, hypotension, orthostasis) are far more reliable indicators of severity.
For variceal bleeding, a critical pearl is that antibiotics are not optional. Students often select octreotide and endoscopy but forget that prophylactic antibiotics (ceftriaxone) are a standard part of the initial management bundle and independently reduce mortality. Another trap: the question may ask about the first step in a known cirrhotic with hematemesis. The answer is resuscitation and stabilization, not endoscopy. Endoscopy is urgent but comes after the patient is hemodynamically supported.
In the differential between Mallory-Weiss and Boerhaave, the discriminator is transmural perforation. The vignette for Boerhaave includes chest pain, subcutaneous emphysema, or pneumomediastinum on imaging. Mallory-Weiss involves hematemesis after vomiting but no perforation signs. Students confuse these two regularly.
For lower GI bleeding in children, always think of Meckel diverticulum when the presentation is painless rectal bleeding in a child under 2. The classic teaching mnemonic is the "rule of 2s": 2% of the population, 2 feet from the ileocecal valve, 2 inches long, presents by age 2, two types of ectopic tissue (gastric and pancreatic). The diagnostic test is a Technetium-99m pertechnetate scan (Meckel scan), which detects ectopic gastric mucosa.
Finally, the aortoenteric fistula is the diagnosis students miss with the worst consequences. Any patient with a prior abdominal aortic aneurysm repair who presents with GI bleeding, even if the initial bleed is small, must be evaluated for this entity. The "herald bleed" concept is a classic exam scenario: a small, self-limited GI bleed in a patient with an aortic graft is not benign and should prompt emergent CT angiography and surgical consultation.
The core competency being tested across GI bleeding questions is the ability to localize the source (upper vs lower), choose the correct initial diagnostic and therapeutic modality, and recognize life-threatening causes that require emergent intervention rather than routine workup.