Demam Rematik Akut
Published on September 11, 2026
Risk Factors
Children aged 5-15 years; overcrowded housing (OR 3.88); low socioeconomic status; poor sanitation; endemic regions (Indonesia classified as moderate-to-high risk); recurrent GAS pharyngitis; limited healthcare access
Etiology
Delayed autoimmune inflammatory response following Group A Streptococcus (GAS / Streptococcus pyogenes) pharyngitis; molecular mimicry between streptococcal antigens and host cardiac tissue
Presentation
A child presenting 1-5 weeks after a sore throat episode with fever, migratory joint pain (large joints), and possibly new cardiac murmur, involuntary movements, or rash
Classic Exam
Migratory polyarthritis of large joints (knees, ankles); new-onset pansystolic or mid-diastolic murmur (mitral/aortic regurgitation); Sydenham chorea (involuntary purposeless movements); erythema marginatum (serpiginous, non-pruritic rash); subcutaneous nodules over bony prominences
Diagnostics
Elevated ESR (≥30 mm/hr in moderate-to-high risk) and CRP (≥3.0 mg/dL); elevated ASTO (≥450 IU) or Anti-DNase B (≥400 IU); prolonged PR interval on ECG; echocardiography showing pathologic regurgitation (mitral or aortic valvulitis); throat culture or rapid antigen test positive for GAS
Management
Eradicate GAS with Benzathine Penicillin G (BPG) IM single dose; anti-inflammatory therapy with naproxen or aspirin for arthritis; corticosteroids (prednisone 1-2 mg/kg/day) for carditis with heart failure; secondary prophylaxis with BPG every 28 days for years
01Pathophysiology
Acute rheumatic fever (ARF) is a non-suppurative, delayed autoimmune complication of pharyngeal infection by Group A Streptococcus (GAS), Streptococcus pyogenes. It is not caused by direct bacterial invasion of the heart or joints. Instead, the disease arises from a misdirected immune response that occurs 1 to 5 weeks after the initial pharyngitis episode.
The central mechanism is molecular mimicry. GAS surface proteins, particularly the M protein, share structural homology with human cardiac myosin, laminin, tropomyosin, and neuronal tissue (basal ganglia). Following pharyngeal infection, the host mounts an antibody and T-cell response against streptococcal antigens. Because of the antigenic cross-reactivity, these immune effectors also target the host's own tissues, resulting in inflammation at several anatomical sites.
Carditis (30-82% of cases) is the hallmark and the most prognostically important manifestation. The inflammatory process targets the endocardium (valvulitis), myocardium, and pericardium. Valvulitis preferentially affects the mitral valve, followed by the aortic valve. The autoimmune assault causes leaflet edema, chordal thickening, and eventually regurgitation. This is why a new-onset pansystolic murmur at the apex (mitral regurgitation) or an early diastolic murmur along the left sternal border (aortic regurgitation) is usually heard. Approximately 50% of patients with carditis will progress to permanent valvular scarring (rheumatic heart disease), making carditis the primary determinant of long-term prognosis.
Arthritis (70-80% of cases) is the most common presenting complaint. The inflammatory mediators deposit in the synovium of large joints, producing the classic migratory polyarthritis. The reason the pain "migrates" is that inflammation in one joint is self-limiting (resolving in days), while new joints become involved sequentially.
Sydenham chorea (10-30%) results from autoantibodies targeting the basal ganglia neurons. The latency for chorea can be longer than for other manifestations, up to 6-8 months, which is why chorea can present as a standalone criterion without concurrent evidence of streptococcal infection.
Erythema marginatum and subcutaneous nodules are rare cutaneous manifestations. Erythema marginatum represents a vasculitic process in the dermal vessels, producing the characteristic serpiginous, non-pruritic, evanescent rash on the trunk and proximal extremities. Subcutaneous nodules consist of perivascular collections of inflammatory cells (resembling Aschoff bodies) located over bony prominences (elbows, knees, wrists, occiput, spinous processes).
A key concept for examination purposes: the disease follows a recurrence-dependent progressive model. Without secondary prophylaxis, each new exposure to a different GAS strain can trigger a new ARF episode, and each episode causes cumulative, worsening valve damage. The risk of recurrence is highest in the first year after the initial attack. This is why lifelong or long-term secondary prophylaxis with BPG is non-negotiable.
02Clinical Manifestation & Classification
The revised 2015 Jones Criteria (AHA) stratify diagnostic criteria based on population risk. Indonesia is classified as a moderate-to-high risk population. This distinction is critical because the threshold for certain criteria differs between groups.
Jones Criteria by Population Risk
Population definition
Moderate-to-High Risk
ARF incidence ≥2/100,000 school-age children/year OR RHD prevalence >1/1,000 all ages
Low-Risk
ARF incidence <2/100,000 school-age children/year OR RHD prevalence ≤1/1,000 all ages
Major: Carditis
Moderate-to-High Risk
Clinical (new murmur) OR subclinical (echo Doppler: pathologic valvulitis per WHF criteria)
Low-Risk
Clinical murmur/valvulitis with echo confirmation
Major: Arthritis
Moderate-to-High Risk
Monoarthritis OR polyarthritis (migratory, large joints) OR polyarthralgia
Low-Risk
Polyarthritis only (migratory, large joints)
Major: Chorea
Moderate-to-High Risk
Sydenham chorea (standalone, no SGA proof required)
Low-Risk
Same
Major: Erythema marginatum
Moderate-to-High Risk
Non-pruritic, serpiginous rash
Low-Risk
Same
Major: Subcutaneous nodules
Moderate-to-High Risk
Firm, painless, over bony prominences
Low-Risk
Same
Minor: Fever
Moderate-to-High Risk
≥38.0 C
Low-Risk
≥38.5 C
Minor: Arthralgia
Moderate-to-High Risk
Monoarthralgia
Low-Risk
Polyarthralgia
Minor: Acute phase reactants
Moderate-to-High Risk
ESR ≥30 mm/hr AND/OR CRP ≥3.0 mg/dL
Low-Risk
ESR ≥60 mm/hr AND/OR CRP ≥3.0 mg/dL
Minor: Prolonged PR interval
Moderate-to-High Risk
Present (consider in context of tachycardia/myocarditis)
Low-Risk
Same
Criterion | Moderate-to-High Risk | Low-Risk |
|---|---|---|
Population definition | ARF incidence ≥2/100,000 school-age children/year OR RHD prevalence >1/1,000 all ages | ARF incidence <2/100,000 school-age children/year OR RHD prevalence ≤1/1,000 all ages |
Major: Carditis | Clinical (new murmur) OR subclinical (echo Doppler: pathologic valvulitis per WHF criteria) | Clinical murmur/valvulitis with echo confirmation |
Major: Arthritis | Monoarthritis OR polyarthritis (migratory, large joints) OR polyarthralgia | Polyarthritis only (migratory, large joints) |
Major: Chorea | Sydenham chorea (standalone, no SGA proof required) | Same |
Major: Erythema marginatum | Non-pruritic, serpiginous rash | Same |
Major: Subcutaneous nodules | Firm, painless, over bony prominences | Same |
Minor: Fever | ≥38.0 C | ≥38.5 C |
Minor: Arthralgia | Monoarthralgia | Polyarthralgia |
Minor: Acute phase reactants | ESR ≥30 mm/hr AND/OR CRP ≥3.0 mg/dL | ESR ≥60 mm/hr AND/OR CRP ≥3.0 mg/dL |
Minor: Prolonged PR interval | Present (consider in context of tachycardia/myocarditis) | Same |
First, in a moderate-to-high risk population, monoarthritis qualifies as a major criterion, whereas in low-risk populations only polyarthritis counts as major. A vignette describing a single swollen, hot knee in a child from an endemic area should still raise your index of suspicion for ARF. Second, the fever threshold is lower (38.0 C vs 38.5 C) and the ESR cutoff is lower (30 vs 60 mm/hr) in the moderate-to-high risk group, making these criteria deliberately more sensitive to avoid missed diagnoses at the cost of reduced specificity.
Diagnostic Combinations Required
Scenario | Combination Required |
|---|---|
Initial attack | 2 major criteria, OR 1 major + 2 minor criteria, PLUS evidence of preceding GAS infection |
Recurrent attack | 2 major, OR 1 major + 2 minor, OR 3 minor criteria, PLUS evidence of preceding GAS infection |
Standalone criteria | Sydenham chorea do NOT require concurrent evidence of GAS infection |
Joint manifestations cannot be double-counted. If polyarthritis is used as a major criterion, arthralgia cannot simultaneously serve as a minor criterion in the same patient.
Clinical Manifestations
Arthritis
Typical Features
Migratory, large joints, exquisitely painful, self-limiting per joint, responds dramatically to NSAIDs
Latency from GAS
1-5 weeks
Carditis
Typical Features
Valvulitis (MR > AR), pericarditis, myocarditis; may be subclinical (echo only)
Latency from GAS
1-5 weeks
Sydenham chorea
Typical Features
Involuntary, purposeless movements; emotional lability; worsening handwriting
Latency from GAS
Up to 6-8 months
Erythema marginatum
Typical Features
Serpiginous, non-pruritic, pink rings on trunk; evanescent
Latency from GAS
1-5 weeks
Subcutaneous nodules
Typical Features
Firm, painless, 0.5-2 cm, over extensor surfaces and bony prominences
Latency from GAS
1-5 weeks
Manifestation | Typical Features | Latency from GAS |
|---|---|---|
Arthritis | Migratory, large joints, exquisitely painful, self-limiting per joint, responds dramatically to NSAIDs | 1-5 weeks |
Carditis | Valvulitis (MR > AR), pericarditis, myocarditis; may be subclinical (echo only) | 1-5 weeks |
Sydenham chorea | Involuntary, purposeless movements; emotional lability; worsening handwriting | Up to 6-8 months |
Erythema marginatum | Serpiginous, non-pruritic, pink rings on trunk; evanescent | 1-5 weeks |
Subcutaneous nodules | Firm, painless, 0.5-2 cm, over extensor surfaces and bony prominences | 1-5 weeks |
03Diagnostic Workup
Throat culture (gold standard for GAS pharyngitis)
Purpose
Confirms GAS etiology
Timing / Notes
Best during acute pharyngitis; positive in carrier state (up to 15% of children), so interpret with clinical context
Rapid antigen detection test (RADT)
Purpose
Quick point-of-care alternative to culture
Timing / Notes
High specificity but variable sensitivity; a negative result does not rule out GAS
ASTO titer
Purpose
Serologic evidence of recent GAS infection
Timing / Notes
Begins rising 1-2 weeks post-infection, peaks at 3-6 weeks, declines over months; elevated ≥450 IU
Anti-DNase B (ADB)
Purpose
Serologic evidence of recent GAS infection
Timing / Notes
Elevated ≥400 IU; particularly useful in skin infections where ASTO may not rise
ESR
Purpose
Acute phase reactant (minor criterion)
Timing / Notes
≥30 mm/hr (moderate-to-high risk) or ≥60 mm/hr (low risk)
CRP
Purpose
Acute phase reactant (minor criterion)
Timing / Notes
≥3.0 mg/dL for both risk groups
ECG
Purpose
Detect conduction abnormalities
Timing / Notes
PR prolongation (minor criterion); also assess for tachycardia disproportionate to fever
Echocardiography (gold standard for carditis/RHD)
Purpose
Detect valvulitis, valve morphology, pericardial effusion, LV function
Timing / Notes
Mandatory in all suspected or confirmed ARF; detects subclinical carditis
CBC
Purpose
Baseline; rule out other etiologies
Timing / Notes
Leukocytosis, anemia of chronic disease
Chest X-ray
Purpose
Assess cardiomegaly, pulmonary congestion
Timing / Notes
For patients with suspected carditis or heart failure
Test | Purpose | Timing / Notes |
|---|---|---|
Throat culture (gold standard for GAS pharyngitis) | Confirms GAS etiology | Best during acute pharyngitis; positive in carrier state (up to 15% of children), so interpret with clinical context |
Rapid antigen detection test (RADT) | Quick point-of-care alternative to culture | High specificity but variable sensitivity; a negative result does not rule out GAS |
ASTO titer | Serologic evidence of recent GAS infection | Begins rising 1-2 weeks post-infection, peaks at 3-6 weeks, declines over months; elevated ≥450 IU |
Anti-DNase B (ADB) | Serologic evidence of recent GAS infection | Elevated ≥400 IU; particularly useful in skin infections where ASTO may not rise |
ESR | Acute phase reactant (minor criterion) | ≥30 mm/hr (moderate-to-high risk) or ≥60 mm/hr (low risk) |
CRP | Acute phase reactant (minor criterion) | ≥3.0 mg/dL for both risk groups |
ECG | Detect conduction abnormalities | PR prolongation (minor criterion); also assess for tachycardia disproportionate to fever |
Echocardiography (gold standard for carditis/RHD) | Detect valvulitis, valve morphology, pericardial effusion, LV function | Mandatory in all suspected or confirmed ARF; detects subclinical carditis |
CBC | Baseline; rule out other etiologies | Leukocytosis, anemia of chronic disease |
Chest X-ray | Assess cardiomegaly, pulmonary congestion | For patients with suspected carditis or heart failure |
Workup Logic in Detail
Step 1: Establish evidence of preceding GAS infection. This is a prerequisite for diagnosis (except for standalone chorea or late-presenting carditis). The Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026 emphasizes that serologic testing (ASTO and Anti-DNase B) is preferred over culture for confirming a causal link, because by the time ARF manifests (weeks later), the pharyngeal infection has often resolved and cultures may be negative. A positive throat culture alone is not strong enough evidence because carrier rates are high, particularly in children (around 15%). Ideally, an elevation in both ASTO and ADB is more convincing than either alone. A four-fold rise in titer between acute and convalescent sera (12-18 days apart) historically represented the strongest evidence, though modern assay methods (turbidimetry, nephelometry) have not been validated for this threshold.
Be aware that ASTO can also be elevated in Bacillus cereus infection, Pseudomonas infections, scarlet fever (Group C Streptococcus), and toxic shock syndrome (Group G Streptococcus). Therefore, an isolated ASTO elevation does not diagnose ARF without clinical correlation.
Step 2: Assess clinical criteria using the Jones framework. Count how many major and minor criteria the patient fulfills. In moderate-to-high risk populations like Indonesia, monoarthritis and subclinical carditis are accepted as major criteria, broadening the diagnostic sensitivity.
Step 3: Echocardiography is mandatory. Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026 states that echocardiography is far more sensitive and specific than auscultation alone for detecting carditis and is therefore obligatory for all patients with suspected or confirmed ARF. Subclinical carditis (valvulitis detected on echo without an audible murmur) is now accepted as a major criterion in both risk groups. The WHF echocardiographic criteria for pathologic mitral regurgitation require all four of: visible in 2 views, jet length >2 cm (or >1.5 cm if body weight <30 kg), velocity >3 m/s for one complete envelope, and pansystolic jet in at least one envelope.
Step 4: Exclude mimics. Before finalizing the diagnosis, rule out congenital heart disease (bicuspid aortic valve, congenital mitral anomalies), septic arthritis, juvenile idiopathic arthritis (JIA), and systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE).
The Best Initial Test in a child with suspected ARF after a recent sore throat is: order ASTO + Anti-DNase B + ESR + CRP + ECG, and refer for echocardiography. The Most Accurate / Confirmatory Test for cardiac involvement is transthoracic echocardiography using Doppler imaging (Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026).
04Management & Treatment
GAS Eradication
Intervention
Benzathine Penicillin G (BPG) IM single dose
Details
≤20 kg: 600,000 IU; >20 kg: 1,200,000 IU. Alternatives: Phenoxymethylpenicillin 15 mg/kg BID x 10 days, or Amoxicillin 50 mg/kg/day x 10 days
Arthritis without carditis
Intervention
Naproxen (first-line)
Details
10-20 mg/kg/day divided BID (max 1,250 mg/day). Alternatives: Ibuprofen 5-10 mg/kg TID (max 2,400 mg/day). Aspirin 50-60 mg/kg/day divided in 4-5 doses as second-line
Mild-moderate carditis
Intervention
NSAIDs for 1-2 weeks, then taper
Details
Naproxen or aspirin; short course corticosteroids for 1 week may be considered
Severe carditis / heart failure
Intervention
Prednisone + heart failure therapy
Details
Prednisone 1-2 mg/kg/day (max 80 mg), once daily or divided, for 1 week then taper 20-25% per week; max 3 weeks total. Discontinue NSAIDs when steroids start
Chorea (moderate-severe)
Intervention
Anticonvulsants
Details
Carbamazepine 3.5-10 mg/kg BID or sodium valproate 7.5-10 mg/kg BID. Severe/paralytic chorea: add prednisolone 1-2 mg/kg (max 80 mg) daily
Pain management
Intervention
Paracetamol (before diagnosis confirmed); NSAIDs (after diagnosis)
Details
Paracetamol 15 mg/kg q4h (max 60 mg/kg/day). Tramadol 1-2 mg/kg q4h for severe pain (avoid in children <12 years)
Secondary prophylaxis
Intervention
BPG IM every 28 days (or every 21 days for high-risk)
Details
Same dosing as eradication. Duration depends on cardiac involvement. Oral alternative: Phenoxymethylpenicillin 250 mg BID
Phase | Intervention | Details |
|---|---|---|
GAS Eradication | Benzathine Penicillin G (BPG) IM single dose | ≤20 kg: 600,000 IU; >20 kg: 1,200,000 IU. Alternatives: Phenoxymethylpenicillin 15 mg/kg BID x 10 days, or Amoxicillin 50 mg/kg/day x 10 days |
Arthritis without carditis | Naproxen (first-line) | 10-20 mg/kg/day divided BID (max 1,250 mg/day). Alternatives: Ibuprofen 5-10 mg/kg TID (max 2,400 mg/day). Aspirin 50-60 mg/kg/day divided in 4-5 doses as second-line |
Mild-moderate carditis | NSAIDs for 1-2 weeks, then taper | Naproxen or aspirin; short course corticosteroids for 1 week may be considered |
Severe carditis / heart failure | Prednisone + heart failure therapy | Prednisone 1-2 mg/kg/day (max 80 mg), once daily or divided, for 1 week then taper 20-25% per week; max 3 weeks total. Discontinue NSAIDs when steroids start |
Chorea (moderate-severe) | Anticonvulsants | Carbamazepine 3.5-10 mg/kg BID or sodium valproate 7.5-10 mg/kg BID. Severe/paralytic chorea: add prednisolone 1-2 mg/kg (max 80 mg) daily |
Pain management | Paracetamol (before diagnosis confirmed); NSAIDs (after diagnosis) | Paracetamol 15 mg/kg q4h (max 60 mg/kg/day). Tramadol 1-2 mg/kg q4h for severe pain (avoid in children <12 years) |
Secondary prophylaxis | BPG IM every 28 days (or every 21 days for high-risk) | Same dosing as eradication. Duration depends on cardiac involvement. Oral alternative: Phenoxymethylpenicillin 250 mg BID |
Acute Stabilization
The immediate priority upon suspecting ARF is twofold: eradicate GAS and control symptoms.
First, administer eradication therapy with BPG intramuscularly (single dose: 600,000 IU for patients ≤20 kg; 1,200,000 IU for patients >20 kg). The intramuscular route is preferred because it guarantees compliance and achieves therapeutic levels reliably. Oral alternatives (Phenoxymethylpenicillin 15 mg/kg BID for 10 days, or Amoxicillin 50 mg/kg once daily for 10 days) are acceptable when IM injection is not possible (Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026, Tabel 3.3). For penicillin-allergic patients: Azithromycin 12 mg/kg/day for 5 days, Erythromycin ethyl succinate 20 mg/kg BID for 10 days, Clindamycin 7-10 mg/kg TID for 10 days, or Cephalexin 25 mg/kg BID for 10 days (for non-anaphylactic allergy only).
Second, manage inflammation. A critical clinical pearl: avoid NSAIDs until the diagnosis is confirmed. Premature NSAID use masks the migratory pattern of arthritis and suppresses fever, potentially causing the patient to no longer meet Jones Criteria. Use paracetamol only for pain relief during the diagnostic workup period.
Arthritis without carditis: Once diagnosis is confirmed, start naproxen (10-20 mg/kg/day divided BID, max 1,250 mg/day) as first-line. Ibuprofen (5-10 mg/kg/dose TID, max 2,400 mg/day) is an acceptable alternative. Aspirin (50-60 mg/kg/day in 4-5 divided doses, can increase to 80-100 mg/kg/day) is second-line due to the risk of Reye syndrome in children. NSAIDs should be tapered after 1-2 weeks based on clinical response and normalization of inflammatory markers.
Carditis: For severe carditis or carditis with heart failure, prednisone 1-2 mg/kg/day (max 80 mg/day) is recommended, given once daily or in divided doses. Treat for 1 week, then taper by 20-25% per week, for a total duration generally not exceeding 3 weeks. When corticosteroids are started, NSAIDs can be discontinued because steroids are more effective at controlling all ARF manifestations. Standard heart failure therapy (diuretics, ACE inhibitors) is given concurrently.
Before initiating immunosuppressive-dose corticosteroids (prednisolone ≥10 mg/day for ≥4 weeks in adults, or >0.5 mg/kg/day for ≥2 weeks in children), screening for latent infections is required: tuberculosis (IGRA or Mantoux), hepatitis B (HBsAg, HBcAb, HBsAb), hepatitis C, HIV, melioidosis, strongyloidiasis, and scabies.
Chorea: Mild cases may not require pharmacologic treatment. Moderate-to-severe chorea is treated with carbamazepine (3.5-10 mg/kg BID) or sodium valproate (7.5-10 mg/kg BID). For very severe or paralytic chorea, add prednisolone.
BPG injection technique: The Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026 describes a lidocaine co-injection technique to reduce pain. Draw the BPG into a new 3 mL syringe, then draw 0.5 mL of 1% lidocaine (or 0.25 mL of 2% lidocaine) into the tip of the same syringe without mixing so that lidocaine is injected first. Administer deep IM into the ventrogluteal site or vastus lateralis, slowly over at least 2-3 minutes. Never administer IV.
Secondary Prophylaxis
ARF without carditis
Minimum Duration
5 years after last episode OR until age 21 (whichever is longer), then reassess
Condition for Stopping
No probable or definite ARF for 5 years AND normal echo
Follow-Up After Stopping
1 year after stopping
ARF with carditis (conduction abnormalities, no persistent RHD)
Minimum Duration
10 years after last episode OR until age 21 (whichever is longer), then reassess
Condition for Stopping
No ARF for 5 years AND normal echo
Follow-Up After Stopping
Years 1, 3, and 5 after stopping
ARF with RHD on echocardiography
Minimum Duration
Duration follows the RHD priority classification
Condition for Stopping
Per RHD-specific guidelines
Follow-Up After Stopping
Per RHD-specific guidelines
Diagnosis | Minimum Duration | Condition for Stopping | Follow-Up After Stopping |
|---|---|---|---|
ARF without carditis | 5 years after last episode OR until age 21 (whichever is longer), then reassess | No probable or definite ARF for 5 years AND normal echo | 1 year after stopping |
ARF with carditis (conduction abnormalities, no persistent RHD) | 10 years after last episode OR until age 21 (whichever is longer), then reassess | No ARF for 5 years AND normal echo | Years 1, 3, and 5 after stopping |
ARF with RHD on echocardiography | Duration follows the RHD priority classification | Per RHD-specific guidelines | Per RHD-specific guidelines |
The regimen of choice is BPG 1,200,000 IU IM every 28 days (every 21 days for select high-risk individuals). If IM is absolutely not possible, oral Phenoxymethylpenicillin 250 mg BID is the oral alternative. For patients with severe penicillin allergy, erythromycin 250 mg BID is used.
Patients already on secondary prophylaxis who develop a new episode of acute pharyngitis should still receive a full course of oral antibiotics (e.g., amoxicillin for 10 days), especially if the last BPG injection was more than 7 days prior, because penicillin levels become subtherapeutic in the 3rd-4th week after injection.
05Differential Diagnosis & Distractors
Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis (JIA)
Why It Is Similar
Polyarthritis in a child with fever and elevated inflammatory markers
Key Discriminator
JIA arthritis is additive and persistent (not migratory and self-limiting). JIA lacks evidence of preceding GAS infection, and echocardiography is normal. JIA does not respond as dramatically to NSAIDs as ARF arthritis does.
Infective Endocarditis
Why It Is Similar
Fever + new murmur + elevated inflammatory markers
Key Discriminator
Blood cultures are positive in IE. Echocardiography shows vegetations on valves rather than diffuse valvulitis. IE often affects previously damaged valves, IV drug users, or patients with prosthetic valves. No migratory arthritis.
Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE)
Why It Is Similar
Polyarthritis + fever + cardiac involvement (Libman-Sacks endocarditis) + rash + elevated ESR
Key Discriminator
SLE has ANA/anti-dsDNA positivity, complement consumption (low C3/C4), malar rash (not erythema marginatum), and renal involvement. No evidence of GAS infection.
Septic Arthritis
Why It Is Similar
Acute hot, swollen, painful joint + fever
Key Discriminator
Septic arthritis is monoarticular (single joint, not migratory). Joint aspiration reveals purulent fluid with high WBC count and positive Gram stain/culture. The child appears more toxic.
Reactive Arthritis (post-infectious)
Why It Is Similar
Arthritis following an infection, with elevated inflammatory markers
Key Discriminator
Reactive arthritis follows GI or GU infections (Chlamydia, Salmonella, Shigella), NOT pharyngeal GAS. It tends to affect lower extremity joints asymmetrically and is associated with urethritis and conjunctivitis. No carditis.
Viral Myocarditis
Why It Is Similar
Tachycardia + new murmur + elevated inflammatory markers + possible heart failure in a young patient
Key Discriminator
Viral myocarditis has diffuse ventricular dysfunction (reduced EF) without isolated valvulitis. No migratory arthritis, no preceding GAS evidence. ECG may show ST changes or arrhythmias rather than isolated PR prolongation.
Congenital Heart Disease (bicuspid aortic valve, congenital mitral anomaly)
Why It Is Similar
Murmur found on echocardiography in a child
Key Discriminator
No inflammatory markers, no preceding GAS infection, no migratory arthritis. The echocardiographic morphology shows congenital anomaly rather than rheumatic valvulitis. This is why echo must exclude congenital causes before diagnosing RHD (Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026, Tabel 2.3).
Innocent (functional) murmur
Why It Is Similar
Murmur heard in a febrile child
Key Discriminator
Functional murmurs are systolic, low-grade, change with position, and have normal echocardiography. They lack the pansystolic or diastolic quality of pathologic regurgitation and have no associated valvular morphology changes on echo.
Differential | Why It Is Similar | Key Discriminator |
|---|---|---|
Juvenile Idiopathic Arthritis (JIA) | Polyarthritis in a child with fever and elevated inflammatory markers | JIA arthritis is additive and persistent (not migratory and self-limiting). JIA lacks evidence of preceding GAS infection, and echocardiography is normal. JIA does not respond as dramatically to NSAIDs as ARF arthritis does. |
Infective Endocarditis | Fever + new murmur + elevated inflammatory markers | Blood cultures are positive in IE. Echocardiography shows vegetations on valves rather than diffuse valvulitis. IE often affects previously damaged valves, IV drug users, or patients with prosthetic valves. No migratory arthritis. |
Systemic Lupus Erythematosus (SLE) | Polyarthritis + fever + cardiac involvement (Libman-Sacks endocarditis) + rash + elevated ESR | SLE has ANA/anti-dsDNA positivity, complement consumption (low C3/C4), malar rash (not erythema marginatum), and renal involvement. No evidence of GAS infection. |
Septic Arthritis | Acute hot, swollen, painful joint + fever | Septic arthritis is monoarticular (single joint, not migratory). Joint aspiration reveals purulent fluid with high WBC count and positive Gram stain/culture. The child appears more toxic. |
Reactive Arthritis (post-infectious) | Arthritis following an infection, with elevated inflammatory markers | Reactive arthritis follows GI or GU infections (Chlamydia, Salmonella, Shigella), NOT pharyngeal GAS. It tends to affect lower extremity joints asymmetrically and is associated with urethritis and conjunctivitis. No carditis. |
Viral Myocarditis | Tachycardia + new murmur + elevated inflammatory markers + possible heart failure in a young patient | Viral myocarditis has diffuse ventricular dysfunction (reduced EF) without isolated valvulitis. No migratory arthritis, no preceding GAS evidence. ECG may show ST changes or arrhythmias rather than isolated PR prolongation. |
Congenital Heart Disease (bicuspid aortic valve, congenital mitral anomaly) | Murmur found on echocardiography in a child | No inflammatory markers, no preceding GAS infection, no migratory arthritis. The echocardiographic morphology shows congenital anomaly rather than rheumatic valvulitis. This is why echo must exclude congenital causes before diagnosing RHD (Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026, Tabel 2.3). |
Innocent (functional) murmur | Murmur heard in a febrile child | Functional murmurs are systolic, low-grade, change with position, and have normal echocardiography. They lack the pansystolic or diastolic quality of pathologic regurgitation and have no associated valvular morphology changes on echo. |
06Traps & High-Yield Pearls
The single most common way students lose points on ARF questions is confusing the role of ASTO with the diagnosis itself. An elevated ASTO does not diagnose ARF. It only provides evidence of a preceding GAS infection. The diagnosis of ARF is clinical, made via the Jones Criteria. Conversely, a normal ASTO does not rule out ARF if Anti-DNase B is elevated, or if the patient presents with standalone chorea (which has a latency of up to 6-8 months, by which time ASTO may have normalized).
The second major trap involves premature NSAID use. A vignette may describe a child with joint pain and fever who is started on ibuprofen by a well-meaning physician. The arthritis resolves, the fever breaks, and now the child no longer meets enough Jones Criteria for diagnosis. The teaching point: use paracetamol only until ARF is confirmed or excluded. Starting NSAIDs too early obscures the migratory pattern and suppresses the fever, both of which are diagnostically critical (Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026, Bab V, Sec. 5.2).
The third common pitfall involves monoarthritis in an endemic population. In a low-risk population, monoarthritis is not a major Jones criterion. But in a moderate-to-high risk population (such as Indonesia), monoarthritis qualifies as major. A question set in a developing country showing a child with a single swollen knee, fever, elevated ASTO, and elevated ESR should prompt you to consider ARF, not dismiss it because "polyarthritis is required."
Fourth, students often forget that subclinical carditis (detected only on echocardiography, with no audible murmur) is now a major criterion in both risk groups. A vignette describing a child who meets one clinical major criterion (e.g., arthritis) and one minor criterion (e.g., fever), and whose echo reveals pathologic mitral regurgitation despite a clean auscultation, now meets 2 major criteria and has confirmed ARF. This is why echocardiography is mandatory for all suspected cases, not optional (Pedoman DRA & PJR PERKI 2026, Bab II, Sec. 2.5).
Fifth, regarding management: corticosteroids for ARF carditis do not prevent progression to RHD. They control acute inflammation and symptoms (fever, pericarditis, heart failure), but no anti-inflammatory therapy has been proven to alter the long-term natural history of valve scarring. The only intervention proven to prevent RHD progression is secondary prophylaxis with BPG by preventing recurrent ARF episodes that cause cumulative valve damage.
The core competency being tested across all ARF questions is threefold: recognizing the disease from its clinical pattern (migratory large-joint arthritis after pharyngitis in a school-age child from an endemic area), applying the correct Jones Criteria tier based on population risk, and understanding that the definitive intervention is not the anti-inflammatory but the lifelong prophylactic BPG that breaks the cycle of recurrence.