Fraktur Antebrachii
Published on September 10, 2026
Risk Factors
Falls on outstretched hand (FOOSH), osteoporosis (elderly women for distal radius fractures), high-energy trauma (young adults, motor vehicle collisions), direct blows (nightstick fracture), pediatric age group (greenstick, torus fractures)
Etiology
Traumatic: FOOSH mechanism (Colles, Smith), direct impact (nightstick), high-energy rotational force (Monteggia, Galeazzi). Pathologic: osteoporosis, metastatic bone disease
Presentation
Pain, swelling, deformity of the forearm or wrist; inability to rotate the forearm (pronation/supination loss suggests radial head or DRUJ involvement); neurovascular complaints distally
Classic Exam
"Dinner fork" deformity (Colles); "garden spade" volar deformity (Smith); shortened radius with prominent ulnar head at the wrist (Galeazzi); loss of radial head contour at the elbow (Monteggia); point tenderness over the ulnar shaft without wrist or elbow instability (nightstick)
Diagnostics
Plain radiographs of the forearm including both the wrist and elbow joints; disruption of the radiocapitellar line on lateral elbow film (Monteggia); widened DRUJ on wrist films (Galeazzi)
Management
Closed reduction and casting for stable, isolated, minimally displaced fractures. Open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) for Monteggia in adults, Galeazzi fractures, both-bone fractures in adults, and any fracture with neurovascular compromise
KEYWORDS
"Dinner fork deformity," "FOOSH," "loss of pronation/supination," "radiocapitellar line disruption," "prominent ulnar head at the wrist," "direct blow to the forearm"
01Pathophysiology
The forearm is a mechanical unit formed by the radius and ulna linked at three points: the proximal radioulnar joint (PRUJ) at the elbow, the interosseous membrane (IOM) running between the two bones, and the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) at the wrist. This ring-like construct means that a fracture of one bone with significant shortening or angulation almost always disrupts the adjacent joint of the other bone. This principle is central to understanding why Monteggia and Galeazzi fracture-dislocations exist as predictable injury patterns rather than random occurrences.
When a patient falls on an outstretched hand, the force is transmitted axially through the wrist. If the wrist is in dorsiflexion, the distal radius fails on its dorsal cortex and the fragment displaces dorsally, producing a Colles fracture. If the wrist is in palmar flexion at impact, the fragment displaces volarly, producing a Smith fracture. The direction of displacement directly explains the resulting deformity on examination: dorsal angulation causes the "dinner fork" silhouette, while volar angulation causes the "garden spade" appearance.
In Monteggia fractures, the mechanism involves a direct blow or a fall with forced pronation. The proximal ulna fractures, and the energy propagates through the IOM to dislocate the radial head at the PRUJ. The radiocapitellar line, a line drawn through the long axis of the radius that should bisect the capitellum in every view, becomes disrupted. This finding is the radiographic hallmark.
In Galeazzi fractures, a fall or direct force fractures the radial shaft at the junction of the middle and distal thirds. The resulting shortening of the radius pulls the DRUJ apart through the IOM. The ulnar head becomes abnormally prominent at the wrist. This is sometimes called a "fracture of necessity" because it almost always requires surgical fixation in adults; closed treatment has an unacceptably high failure rate due to the deforming muscular forces (pronator quadratus, brachioradialis).
The nightstick fracture, an isolated ulnar shaft fracture from a direct blow (historically from blocking a strike with the forearm), is unique because it does not disrupt the ring construct if there is no significant displacement. This is why it is the one forearm shaft fracture that can often be treated nonoperatively.
In children, the periosteum is thick and the bone is more porous, leading to incomplete fracture patterns. A torus (buckle) fracture compresses one cortex without disrupting the other. A greenstick fracture breaks the tension-side cortex while bending the compression side. These heal rapidly and are treated with immobilization rather than surgery.
02Classification and Clinical Manifestation
Colles fracture
MECHANISM
FOOSH, wrist in dorsiflexion
BONE INVOLVED
Distal radius (extra-articular)
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
None typically
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Dinner fork deformity (dorsal displacement)
Smith fracture
MECHANISM
FOOSH, wrist in palmar flexion or direct dorsal blow
BONE INVOLVED
Distal radius
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
None typically
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Garden spade deformity (volar displacement)
Barton fracture
MECHANISM
FOOSH or direct force
BONE INVOLVED
Distal radius (intra-articular)
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
Radiocarpal subluxation
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Wrist subluxation with intra-articular step-off
Monteggia fracture
MECHANISM
Direct blow, forced pronation
BONE INVOLVED
Proximal ulna shaft
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
Radial head dislocation (PRUJ)
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Loss of radial head contour at elbow, disrupted radiocapitellar line
Galeazzi fracture
MECHANISM
FOOSH, direct blow
BONE INVOLVED
Distal one-third radius shaft
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
DRUJ dislocation
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Prominent ulnar head at the wrist, wrist instability
Nightstick fracture
MECHANISM
Direct blow to ulnar border
BONE INVOLVED
Ulnar shaft (isolated)
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
None (ring intact if minimal displacement)
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Point tenderness, minimal deformity
Both-bone fracture
MECHANISM
High-energy trauma
BONE INVOLVED
Radius and ulna shafts
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
Variable
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Gross forearm deformity, rotational malalignment
Greenstick fracture (pediatric)
MECHANISM
Bending force
BONE INVOLVED
Radius and/or ulna
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
None
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Angulation without complete cortical break
Torus (buckle) fracture (pediatric)
MECHANISM
Axial compression
BONE INVOLVED
Distal radius (usually)
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
None
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Subtle cortical buckling, minimal swelling
Essex-Lopresti injury
MECHANISM
Axial load through the wrist
BONE INVOLVED
Radial head fracture
ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY
IOM tear + DRUJ disruption
CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING
Proximal forearm pain with wrist instability
FRACTURE TYPE | MECHANISM | BONE INVOLVED | ASSOCIATED JOINT INJURY | CLASSIC DEFORMITY OR FINDING |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Colles fracture | FOOSH, wrist in dorsiflexion | Distal radius (extra-articular) | None typically | Dinner fork deformity (dorsal displacement) |
Smith fracture | FOOSH, wrist in palmar flexion or direct dorsal blow | Distal radius | None typically | Garden spade deformity (volar displacement) |
Barton fracture | FOOSH or direct force | Distal radius (intra-articular) | Radiocarpal subluxation | Wrist subluxation with intra-articular step-off |
Monteggia fracture | Direct blow, forced pronation | Proximal ulna shaft | Radial head dislocation (PRUJ) | Loss of radial head contour at elbow, disrupted radiocapitellar line |
Galeazzi fracture | FOOSH, direct blow | Distal one-third radius shaft | DRUJ dislocation | Prominent ulnar head at the wrist, wrist instability |
Nightstick fracture | Direct blow to ulnar border | Ulnar shaft (isolated) | None (ring intact if minimal displacement) | Point tenderness, minimal deformity |
Both-bone fracture | High-energy trauma | Radius and ulna shafts | Variable | Gross forearm deformity, rotational malalignment |
Greenstick fracture (pediatric) | Bending force | Radius and/or ulna | None | Angulation without complete cortical break |
Torus (buckle) fracture (pediatric) | Axial compression | Distal radius (usually) | None | Subtle cortical buckling, minimal swelling |
Essex-Lopresti injury | Axial load through the wrist | Radial head fracture | IOM tear + DRUJ disruption | Proximal forearm pain with wrist instability |
Monteggia Classification (Bado)
Type I
ULNA FRACTURE ANGULATION
Anterior (apex anterior)
RADIAL HEAD DISLOCATION DIRECTION
Anterior
FREQUENCY
Most common (60-70%)
Type II
ULNA FRACTURE ANGULATION
Posterior (apex posterior)
RADIAL HEAD DISLOCATION DIRECTION
Posterior
FREQUENCY
Second most common
Type III
ULNA FRACTURE ANGULATION
Lateral
RADIAL HEAD DISLOCATION DIRECTION
Lateral
FREQUENCY
Less common
Type IV
ULNA FRACTURE ANGULATION
Anterior
RADIAL HEAD DISLOCATION DIRECTION
Anterior + proximal radius fracture
FREQUENCY
Rare
TYPE | ULNA FRACTURE ANGULATION | RADIAL HEAD DISLOCATION DIRECTION | FREQUENCY |
|---|---|---|---|
Type I | Anterior (apex anterior) | Anterior | Most common (60-70%) |
Type II | Posterior (apex posterior) | Posterior | Second most common |
Type III | Lateral | Lateral | Less common |
Type IV | Anterior | Anterior + proximal radius fracture | Rare |
03Diagnostic Workup
Plain radiographs of the forearm (AP and lateral, including wrist and elbow joints)
PURPOSE
Best initial test for all forearm fractures
KEY FINDINGS
Fracture line, displacement, angulation, joint congruity
Radiocapitellar line assessment (lateral elbow view)
PURPOSE
Screen for Monteggia fracture-dislocation
KEY FINDINGS
Line through the radial shaft should bisect the capitellum in every view; failure to do so confirms radial head dislocation
DRUJ assessment (PA wrist view)
PURPOSE
Screen for Galeazzi injury
KEY FINDINGS
Widened DRUJ space, ulnar styloid fracture, dorsal subluxation of the ulna
CT scan
PURPOSE
Most accurate test for intra-articular fractures (Barton) or complex comminution
KEY FINDINGS
Defines articular step-off, fragment size, surgical planning
MRI
PURPOSE
Evaluate ligamentous injury, IOM integrity, occult fractures
KEY FINDINGS
IOM tear in Essex-Lopresti, TFCC injury, occult scaphoid fracture
Neurovascular examination (clinical)
PURPOSE
Mandatory in every forearm fracture
KEY FINDINGS
Median nerve (anterior interosseous branch in Monteggia), posterior interosseous nerve (PIN) in Monteggia type II, ulnar nerve in distal fractures
TEST | PURPOSE | KEY FINDINGS |
|---|---|---|
Plain radiographs of the forearm (AP and lateral, including wrist and elbow joints) | Best initial test for all forearm fractures | Fracture line, displacement, angulation, joint congruity |
Radiocapitellar line assessment (lateral elbow view) | Screen for Monteggia fracture-dislocation | Line through the radial shaft should bisect the capitellum in every view; failure to do so confirms radial head dislocation |
DRUJ assessment (PA wrist view) | Screen for Galeazzi injury | Widened DRUJ space, ulnar styloid fracture, dorsal subluxation of the ulna |
CT scan | Most accurate test for intra-articular fractures (Barton) or complex comminution | Defines articular step-off, fragment size, surgical planning |
MRI | Evaluate ligamentous injury, IOM integrity, occult fractures | IOM tear in Essex-Lopresti, TFCC injury, occult scaphoid fracture |
Neurovascular examination (clinical) | Mandatory in every forearm fracture | Median nerve (anterior interosseous branch in Monteggia), posterior interosseous nerve (PIN) in Monteggia type II, ulnar nerve in distal fractures |
The best initial test for any suspected forearm fracture is plain radiography of the entire forearm, and the single most important principle is that films must include both the joint above and the joint below the injury. The most commonly tested error on exams is obtaining only a wrist film for a distal radius fracture without imaging the elbow, thereby missing a concomitant dislocation (Essex-Lopresti) or the reverse pattern.
When you see a proximal ulna fracture on film, your next step must be to carefully evaluate the lateral elbow radiograph for the radiocapitellar line. Draw a line along the axis of the proximal radius; it must pass through the center of the capitellum on every projection (AP, lateral, oblique). Disruption of this line is the radiographic confirmation of a Monteggia fracture-dislocation. This is a favorite exam image because students focus on the obvious ulna fracture and fail to recognize the subtle radial head dislocation.
For a radius shaft fracture, the next step is evaluating the DRUJ on the wrist film. Widening of the DRUJ, a fracture of the ulnar styloid process, or dorsal subluxation of the distal ulna all suggest a Galeazzi pattern. If clinical suspicion remains high but plain films are equivocal, a CT of the wrist can better define the articular surface and DRUJ congruity.
CT scanning is reserved for intra-articular fractures (Barton fracture, comminuted distal radius fractures) to guide surgical planning. It is the most accurate test for defining the number, size, and displacement of articular fragments.
A thorough neurovascular examination is not optional. The anterior interosseous nerve (AIN), a motor branch of the median nerve, is at risk in Monteggia fractures and proximal forearm injuries. Test AIN function by asking the patient to make an "OK" sign (pinch with the thumb IP joint and index DIP joint flexed). The posterior interosseous nerve (PIN) is at risk in Monteggia type II fractures and proximal radius fractures; test by asking for finger extension at the MCP joints. Median nerve compression (especially acute carpal tunnel syndrome) can complicate displaced distal radius fractures and constitutes an emergency requiring urgent reduction or surgical release.
04Management and Treatment
Colles fracture (stable, extra-articular, minimal displacement)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Hematoma block or procedural sedation, closed reduction
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Sugar-tong splint then short arm cast for 4-6 weeks
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Acceptable alignment: less than 2 mm shortening, less than 5 degrees dorsal tilt, no intra-articular step-off greater than 2 mm
Colles fracture (unstable, comminuted, intra-articular)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Closed reduction and splinting
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF with volar locking plate
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Indications for surgery: intra-articular involvement, more than 2 mm articular step-off, significant radial shortening, instability after reduction
Smith fracture
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Closed reduction
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF with volar plate (most cases require surgery)
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Volar displacement is inherently unstable; high rate of re-displacement in a cast
Barton fracture
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Splinting
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF with buttress plate
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Intra-articular by definition; nonoperative treatment yields poor outcomes
Monteggia fracture (adult)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Splint, urgent referral
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF of the ulna + closed reduction of radial head
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Anatomic reduction of the ulna typically restores the radial head; if the radial head remains dislocated after ulna fixation, open reduction is required
Monteggia fracture (pediatric)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Closed reduction under sedation
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Long arm cast for 6 weeks
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Children tolerate closed management well; surgical fixation only if closed reduction fails
Galeazzi fracture (adult)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Splint
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF of the radius + DRUJ assessment intraoperatively
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Called "fracture of necessity" because nonoperative treatment fails in adults; DRUJ stability must be assessed after radius fixation
Galeazzi fracture (pediatric)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Closed reduction
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Long arm cast in supination for 6 weeks
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Children can be managed closed; adults cannot
Nightstick fracture (less than 50% displacement, less than 10 degrees angulation)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Immobilization
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Functional brace or short arm cast for 6-8 weeks
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Only forearm shaft fracture in adults routinely treated nonoperatively
Nightstick fracture (displaced or angulated beyond thresholds)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Splint
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF with plate and screws
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Treat like any displaced shaft fracture
Both-bone forearm fracture (adult)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Splint
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
ORIF of both radius and ulna
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Adult both-bone fractures are virtually always surgical
Both-bone forearm fracture (pediatric)
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Closed reduction
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Long arm cast for 6-8 weeks
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Children have significant remodeling potential; surgical fixation with elastic nails if reduction is unacceptable
Torus (buckle) fracture
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Removable wrist splint
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Splint for 3-4 weeks, clinical follow-up
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Stable injury; does not require casting or repeat radiographs in most protocols
Greenstick fracture
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Closed reduction if significantly angulated
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Long arm cast for 4-6 weeks
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Must complete the fracture or correct angulation to prevent re-deformation in the cast
Essex-Lopresti injury
INITIAL MANAGEMENT
Splint, urgent surgical referral
DEFINITIVE TREATMENT
Radial head fixation or prosthetic replacement + IOM reconstruction + DRUJ stabilization
KEY CONSIDERATIONS
Do NOT excise the radial head; loss of the radial head allows proximal migration of the radius and worsens DRUJ instability
FRACTURE TYPE | INITIAL MANAGEMENT | DEFINITIVE TREATMENT | KEY CONSIDERATIONS |
|---|---|---|---|
Colles fracture (stable, extra-articular, minimal displacement) | Hematoma block or procedural sedation, closed reduction | Sugar-tong splint then short arm cast for 4-6 weeks | Acceptable alignment: less than 2 mm shortening, less than 5 degrees dorsal tilt, no intra-articular step-off greater than 2 mm |
Colles fracture (unstable, comminuted, intra-articular) | Closed reduction and splinting | ORIF with volar locking plate | Indications for surgery: intra-articular involvement, more than 2 mm articular step-off, significant radial shortening, instability after reduction |
Smith fracture | Closed reduction | ORIF with volar plate (most cases require surgery) | Volar displacement is inherently unstable; high rate of re-displacement in a cast |
Barton fracture | Splinting | ORIF with buttress plate | Intra-articular by definition; nonoperative treatment yields poor outcomes |
Monteggia fracture (adult) | Splint, urgent referral | ORIF of the ulna + closed reduction of radial head | Anatomic reduction of the ulna typically restores the radial head; if the radial head remains dislocated after ulna fixation, open reduction is required |
Monteggia fracture (pediatric) | Closed reduction under sedation | Long arm cast for 6 weeks | Children tolerate closed management well; surgical fixation only if closed reduction fails |
Galeazzi fracture (adult) | Splint | ORIF of the radius + DRUJ assessment intraoperatively | Called "fracture of necessity" because nonoperative treatment fails in adults; DRUJ stability must be assessed after radius fixation |
Galeazzi fracture (pediatric) | Closed reduction | Long arm cast in supination for 6 weeks | Children can be managed closed; adults cannot |
Nightstick fracture (less than 50% displacement, less than 10 degrees angulation) | Immobilization | Functional brace or short arm cast for 6-8 weeks | Only forearm shaft fracture in adults routinely treated nonoperatively |
Nightstick fracture (displaced or angulated beyond thresholds) | Splint | ORIF with plate and screws | Treat like any displaced shaft fracture |
Both-bone forearm fracture (adult) | Splint | ORIF of both radius and ulna | Adult both-bone fractures are virtually always surgical |
Both-bone forearm fracture (pediatric) | Closed reduction | Long arm cast for 6-8 weeks | Children have significant remodeling potential; surgical fixation with elastic nails if reduction is unacceptable |
Torus (buckle) fracture | Removable wrist splint | Splint for 3-4 weeks, clinical follow-up | Stable injury; does not require casting or repeat radiographs in most protocols |
Greenstick fracture | Closed reduction if significantly angulated | Long arm cast for 4-6 weeks | Must complete the fracture or correct angulation to prevent re-deformation in the cast |
Essex-Lopresti injury | Splint, urgent surgical referral | Radial head fixation or prosthetic replacement + IOM reconstruction + DRUJ stabilization | Do NOT excise the radial head; loss of the radial head allows proximal migration of the radius and worsens DRUJ instability |
Acute Stabilization
The immediate priorities are analgesia, assessment for neurovascular compromise, and splinting in a position of comfort. For displaced distal radius fractures, perform closed reduction using a hematoma block (inject 5-10 mL of 1% lidocaine without epinephrine directly into the fracture hematoma) or procedural sedation. Apply longitudinal traction, disimpact the fragment, and correct the deformity. After reduction, apply a well-padded sugar-tong splint to prevent pronation and supination while allowing for swelling. The splint extends from the dorsal MCP joints, around the elbow at 90 degrees of flexion, to the volar MCP joints.
For all shaft fractures (Monteggia, Galeazzi, both-bone), initial management is a long arm splint with the elbow at 90 degrees and the forearm in neutral or the position of stability, followed by urgent orthopedic referral.
Compartment syndrome of the forearm is a surgical emergency that can complicate any forearm fracture. The hallmark is pain out of proportion to the injury, especially pain with passive extension of the fingers. If compartment syndrome is suspected, all circumferential dressings must be removed immediately and the compartment pressure measured. Pressures within 30 mmHg of the diastolic blood pressure (delta pressure less than or equal to 30 mmHg) or absolute pressures above 30 mmHg are indications for emergent fasciotomy. Do not wait for the "classic" signs of pallor and pulselessness; these are late and indicate irreversible damage.
Definitive (Long-Term) Management
For Colles fractures, if the reduction is stable and the fracture meets alignment criteria, transition from splint to a short arm cast at 1-2 weeks when swelling subsides, and immobilize for a total of 4-6 weeks. If instability is present (comminution, loss of reduction on follow-up films, intra-articular extension), proceed to ORIF with a volar locking plate.
Galeazzi fractures in adults always require ORIF of the radius. After fixation, the DRUJ is tested intraoperatively. If stable, the arm is immobilized in supination. If unstable, the DRUJ is pinned with K-wires or repaired.
Monteggia fractures in adults require ORIF of the ulna. Anatomic reduction of the ulna length and alignment will usually reduce the radial head indirectly. A post-fixation radiograph must confirm restoration of the radiocapitellar line.
Contraindications and Cautions: In the elderly osteoporotic patient with a distal radius fracture, hardware fixation into severely osteoporotic bone has higher complication rates (screw cutout, plate failure). Fragment-specific fixation, external fixation, or augmentation with bone cement may be preferred. In open fractures, administer IV antibiotics (typically a first-generation cephalosporin such as cefazolin 2 g IV; add an aminoglycoside for grossly contaminated wounds), administer tetanus prophylaxis if indicated, and perform urgent irrigation and debridement in the operating room before definitive fixation.
05Differential Diagnosis and Distractors
Scaphoid fracture
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Also caused by FOOSH; wrist pain and swelling
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Snuffbox tenderness, pain with axial loading of the thumb; initial radiographs may be negative (repeat films or MRI at 10-14 days); no dorsal deformity of the wrist
Distal humerus fracture (supracondylar)
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Elbow pain after a fall in a child; swelling and deformity around the elbow
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Posterior fat pad sign on lateral elbow film; fracture line is supracondylar, not in the forearm; associated with brachial artery injury and Volkmann ischemic contracture
Elbow dislocation
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Loss of elbow motion after trauma; swelling and deformity at the elbow
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Olecranon is prominent posteriorly; no ulnar shaft fracture line on radiograph (unlike Monteggia); radiographs show ulnohumeral incongruity
Radial head fracture (isolated)
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Elbow pain after FOOSH; limited forearm rotation
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Positive fat pad sign; fracture visible at the radial head/neck without ulnar shaft involvement; must rule out Essex-Lopresti by examining the wrist
Forearm compartment syndrome
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Forearm pain and swelling after trauma; can accompany any forearm fracture
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Pain with passive finger extension is out of proportion; tense forearm compartments on palpation; this is a complication, not a fracture pattern, and requires emergent fasciotomy
Plastic deformation (pediatric)
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Forearm bowing without a visible fracture line; follows a fall
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
Radiograph shows bowing deformity of the bone without a discrete fracture line; unique to children due to bone plasticity
DRUJ sprain or subluxation (without fracture)
WHY IT IS SIMILAR
Wrist pain with loss of pronation/supination after trauma
KEY DISCRIMINATOR
No radius shaft fracture on radiograph; isolated DRUJ tenderness and instability; absence of the fracture component distinguishes this from Galeazzi
DIFFERENTIAL | WHY IT IS SIMILAR | KEY DISCRIMINATOR |
|---|---|---|
Scaphoid fracture | Also caused by FOOSH; wrist pain and swelling | Snuffbox tenderness, pain with axial loading of the thumb; initial radiographs may be negative (repeat films or MRI at 10-14 days); no dorsal deformity of the wrist |
Distal humerus fracture (supracondylar) | Elbow pain after a fall in a child; swelling and deformity around the elbow | Posterior fat pad sign on lateral elbow film; fracture line is supracondylar, not in the forearm; associated with brachial artery injury and Volkmann ischemic contracture |
Elbow dislocation | Loss of elbow motion after trauma; swelling and deformity at the elbow | Olecranon is prominent posteriorly; no ulnar shaft fracture line on radiograph (unlike Monteggia); radiographs show ulnohumeral incongruity |
Radial head fracture (isolated) | Elbow pain after FOOSH; limited forearm rotation | Positive fat pad sign; fracture visible at the radial head/neck without ulnar shaft involvement; must rule out Essex-Lopresti by examining the wrist |
Forearm compartment syndrome | Forearm pain and swelling after trauma; can accompany any forearm fracture | Pain with passive finger extension is out of proportion; tense forearm compartments on palpation; this is a complication, not a fracture pattern, and requires emergent fasciotomy |
Plastic deformation (pediatric) | Forearm bowing without a visible fracture line; follows a fall | Radiograph shows bowing deformity of the bone without a discrete fracture line; unique to children due to bone plasticity |
DRUJ sprain or subluxation (without fracture) | Wrist pain with loss of pronation/supination after trauma | No radius shaft fracture on radiograph; isolated DRUJ tenderness and instability; absence of the fracture component distinguishes this from Galeazzi |
06Traps and High-Yield Pearls
The single most common way students lose points on forearm fracture questions is by failing to recognize the associated joint injury. A vignette will show you a clear ulnar shaft fracture and ask for the next step or the diagnosis. The trap answer is "isolated ulnar shaft fracture" or "nightstick fracture." The correct answer is to recognize it as a Monteggia fracture by noting clues like loss of elbow extension, a disrupted radiocapitellar line, or an instruction in the stem saying the elbow films are abnormal. The same logic applies to Galeazzi: if you see a radius shaft fracture, you must check the DRUJ. The tested principle is that the forearm is a ring structure, and a displaced fracture of one bone must disrupt the ring somewhere else.
A second frequent trap involves compartment syndrome. The question will describe a patient with a forearm fracture who, hours later, has worsening pain despite adequate analgesia and pain with passive finger extension. The distractor answer is to order more imaging or increase pain medication. The correct answer is always to measure compartment pressures and proceed to fasciotomy.
For pediatric questions, remember that children remodel bone far better than adults. The tested concept is that most pediatric forearm fractures, including Monteggia and Galeazzi patterns, can be managed with closed reduction and casting, while the same fractures in adults almost universally require ORIF. A torus fracture requires only a removable splint, not a circumferential cast, and does not need repeat radiographs.
Finally, do not confuse the names: Monteggia is proximal ulna plus radial head dislocation (think "MU" for Monteggia-Ulna); Galeazzi is radius shaft plus DRUJ dislocation (think "GR" for Galeazzi-Radius). Reversing these is one of the most common errors on timed exams.