Gangguan Asam-Basa
Published on September 6, 2026
Risk Factors
Varies by disorder: COPD/sedative overdose (respiratory acidosis), hyperventilation/anxiety/PE (respiratory alkalosis), DKA/renal failure/toxins (metabolic acidosis), vomiting/diuretics (metabolic alkalosis)
Etiology
Imbalance between acid production/excretion and buffer systems involving (respiratory component) and (metabolic component)
Presentation
Altered mental status, Kussmaul breathing, tetany, arrhythmias, confusion, depending on the type and severity
Classic Exam
Kussmaul breathing (metabolic acidosis), shallow breathing (metabolic alkalosis), carpopedal spasm/Chvostek sign (respiratory alkalosis), narcosis/somnolence (respiratory acidosis)
Diagnostics
Arterial blood gas (ABG): pH, , ; serum electrolytes for anion gap; urine electrolytes when needed
Management
Treat the underlying cause first; bicarbonate replacement only in severe metabolic acidosis (); acetazolamide for metabolic alkalosis; ventilatory support for respiratory disorders
Keywords
Kussmaul breathing, anion gap, Winter's formula, delta-delta, compensation, MUDPILES, HARDUPS, contraction alkalosis, saline-responsive vs. saline-resistant
00Foundation
Before diving into individual disorders, you need a bulletproof algorithm. Every exam question on acid-base gives you an ABG and expects you to identify: (1) the primary disorder, (2) whether compensation is present, and (3) whether compensation is appropriate or a second disorder is hiding.
Normal Values You Must Memorize
Parameter | Normal Value |
|---|---|
pH | 7.35 to 7.45 |
35 to 45 mmHg | |
22 to 26 mEq/L |
The 5-Step ABG Interpretation Algorithm
Step 1: Look at the pH. If , the primary process is an acidosis. If , the primary process is an alkalosis. If the pH is normal (7.35 to 7.45), look at the other values because a mixed disorder or full compensation may be present.
Step 2: Identify the primary disorder. Match the pH direction with the deranged component. Ask: "Which value explains the pH?"
Acidemia ()
If is the culprit
= Respiratory Acidosis
If is the culprit
= Metabolic Acidosis
Alkalemia ()
If is the culprit
= Respiratory Alkalosis
If is the culprit
= Metabolic Alkalosis
pH direction | If is the culprit | If is the culprit |
|---|---|---|
Acidemia () | = Respiratory Acidosis | = Metabolic Acidosis |
Alkalemia () | = Respiratory Alkalosis | = Metabolic Alkalosis |
Step 3: Check for compensation. The body never overcompensates. The compensatory response always moves in the same direction as the primary change. This is a fundamental rule that exam writers exploit.
Step 4: If metabolic acidosis is present, calculate the anion gap.
Step 5: If an elevated anion gap is found, calculate the delta-delta ratio to check for a hidden second metabolic disorder.
01Pathophysiology
The body maintains blood pH within a narrow range of 7.35 to 7.45 through three integrated systems: chemical buffers (bicarbonate being the most important), respiratory regulation of , and renal regulation of .
The relationship is captured by the Henderson-Hasselbalch equation:
This equation is the single most important concept in acid-base physiology. It tells you that pH depends on the ratio of bicarbonate to carbon dioxide, not their absolute values. This is why compensation works: if one side changes, the other side shifts in the same direction to preserve the ratio and bring pH back toward normal.
Respiratory disorders arise from changes in . Carbon dioxide is a volatile acid. When ventilation decreases, accumulates and pH drops (respiratory acidosis). When ventilation increases, is blown off and pH rises (respiratory alkalosis). The kidneys compensate over days by adjusting reabsorption.
Metabolic disorders arise from changes in . When bicarbonate is consumed (by acid loads) or lost (through the GI tract or kidneys), pH drops (metabolic acidosis). When bicarbonate accumulates (from vomiting, diuretics, or excess alkali), pH rises (metabolic alkalosis). The lungs compensate within minutes to hours by adjusting ventilation.
A critical teaching point: respiratory compensation is fast (minutes to hours) but limited, while renal compensation is slow (3 to 5 days) but more powerful. This is why you must distinguish acute from chronic respiratory disorders; the expected compensation values are different.
02Classification and Clinical Manifestation
The Four Primary Disorders
Respiratory Acidosis
pH
Low
Primary Change
elevated
Compensation
rises
Clinical Setting
COPD exacerbation, opioid overdose, neuromuscular disease, obesity hypoventilation
Respiratory Alkalosis
pH
High
Primary Change
decreased
Compensation
falls
Clinical Setting
Anxiety/panic, early PE, early sepsis, salicylate toxicity (early), pregnancy, high altitude, liver cirrhosis
Metabolic Acidosis
pH
Low
Primary Change
decreased
Compensation
falls
Clinical Setting
DKA, lactic acidosis, renal failure, diarrhea, RTA, toxic ingestions
Metabolic Alkalosis
pH
High
Primary Change
elevated
Compensation
rises
Clinical Setting
Vomiting/NG suction, diuretic use, hyperaldosteronism, Cushing syndrome
Disorder | pH | Primary Change | Compensation | Clinical Setting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Respiratory Acidosis | Low | elevated | rises | COPD exacerbation, opioid overdose, neuromuscular disease, obesity hypoventilation |
Respiratory Alkalosis | High | decreased | falls | Anxiety/panic, early PE, early sepsis, salicylate toxicity (early), pregnancy, high altitude, liver cirrhosis |
Metabolic Acidosis | Low | decreased | falls | DKA, lactic acidosis, renal failure, diarrhea, RTA, toxic ingestions |
Metabolic Alkalosis | High | elevated | rises | Vomiting/NG suction, diuretic use, hyperaldosteronism, Cushing syndrome |
Clinical Manifestations by System
Neurological
Acidosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Confusion, somnolence, coma (especially respiratory acidosis with narcosis)
Alkalosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Light-headedness, confusion, seizures (severe alkalosis)
Respiratory
Acidosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Kussmaul breathing (deep, rapid) in metabolic acidosis; shallow/slow breathing in respiratory acidosis
Alkalosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Hyperventilation in respiratory alkalosis; hypoventilation (compensatory) in metabolic alkalosis
Cardiovascular
Acidosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Decreased myocardial contractility, vasodilation, predisposition to arrhythmias; hyperkalemia shifts
Alkalosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Arrhythmias (especially with concurrent hypokalemia); hypokalemia shifts
Neuromuscular
Acidosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Hyperkalemia-related weakness
Alkalosis (Respiratory or Metabolic)
Tetany, carpopedal spasm, perioral tingling (from decreased ionized calcium in alkalosis)
System | Acidosis (Respiratory or Metabolic) | Alkalosis (Respiratory or Metabolic) |
|---|---|---|
Neurological | Confusion, somnolence, coma (especially respiratory acidosis with narcosis) | Light-headedness, confusion, seizures (severe alkalosis) |
Respiratory | Kussmaul breathing (deep, rapid) in metabolic acidosis; shallow/slow breathing in respiratory acidosis | Hyperventilation in respiratory alkalosis; hypoventilation (compensatory) in metabolic alkalosis |
Cardiovascular | Decreased myocardial contractility, vasodilation, predisposition to arrhythmias; hyperkalemia shifts | Arrhythmias (especially with concurrent hypokalemia); hypokalemia shifts |
Neuromuscular | Hyperkalemia-related weakness | Tetany, carpopedal spasm, perioral tingling (from decreased ionized calcium in alkalosis) |
The connection between acid-base status and potassium is heavily tested. In acidosis, enters cells and exits, causing hyperkalemia. In alkalosis, the reverse occurs, causing hypokalemia. This is why DKA patients present with high serum potassium despite having total body potassium depletion; once insulin and fluids correct the acidosis, potassium plummets.
03Compensation
This section is the backbone of every exam question on acid-base disorders. You are not simply being tested on whether you can identify a disorder. You are being tested on whether you can determine if the compensation is appropriate. If the measured compensatory value does not match the predicted value, a second (hidden) disorder exists.
Definitions
Uncompensated
Definition
Only the primary value is abnormal; the compensatory parameter has not yet changed
pH
Clearly abnormal
What It Means
The disorder is very acute (minutes old) or the compensatory organ has failed
Partially Compensated
Definition
Both the primary value and the compensatory value are abnormal, but pH remains outside normal range
pH
Abnormal, but closer to normal than uncompensated
What It Means
The body is responding but has not had enough time or capacity to normalize pH
Fully Compensated
Definition
Both the primary value and compensatory value are abnormal, but pH has returned to the normal range (7.35 to 7.45)
pH
Normal range (but look at which side of 7.40 it falls on)
What It Means
Enough time has passed for the compensatory system to bring pH back
Status | Definition | pH | What It Means |
|---|---|---|---|
Uncompensated | Only the primary value is abnormal; the compensatory parameter has not yet changed | Clearly abnormal | The disorder is very acute (minutes old) or the compensatory organ has failed |
Partially Compensated | Both the primary value and the compensatory value are abnormal, but pH remains outside normal range | Abnormal, but closer to normal than uncompensated | The body is responding but has not had enough time or capacity to normalize pH |
Fully Compensated | Both the primary value and compensatory value are abnormal, but pH has returned to the normal range (7.35 to 7.45) | Normal range (but look at which side of 7.40 it falls on) | Enough time has passed for the compensatory system to bring pH back |
When pH is normal but both and are abnormal, you have a fully compensated disorder. To determine the primary disorder, look at which side of 7.40 the pH falls. A pH of 7.37 (low-normal) suggests a compensated acidosis. A pH of 7.43 (high-normal) suggests a compensated alkalosis. The body never overcompensates.
The Compensation Formulas
Metabolic Acidosis
Expected Compensation
drops
Formula
Winter's Formula:
Metabolic Alkalosis
Expected Compensation
rises
Formula
Acute Respiratory Acidosis
Expected Compensation
rises
Formula
For every , rises by 1
Chronic Respiratory Acidosis
Expected Compensation
rises
Formula
For every , rises by 3.5
Acute Respiratory Alkalosis
Expected Compensation
falls
Formula
For every , falls by 2
Chronic Respiratory Alkalosis
Expected Compensation
falls
Formula
For every , falls by 5
Primary Disorder | Expected Compensation | Formula |
|---|---|---|
Metabolic Acidosis | drops | Winter's Formula: |
Metabolic Alkalosis | rises | |
Acute Respiratory Acidosis | rises | For every , rises by 1 |
Chronic Respiratory Acidosis | rises | For every , rises by 3.5 |
Acute Respiratory Alkalosis | falls | For every , falls by 2 |
Chronic Respiratory Alkalosis | falls | For every , falls by 5 |
How to Apply These Formulas
Example: A patient has pH 7.30, 30, 14.
Step 1: pH is low, so this is an acidosis. Step 2: is low (14), which explains the low pH. This is a metabolic acidosis. Step 3: The is 30, which is below normal. This is expected respiratory compensation (hyperventilation). But is it appropriate?
Apply Winter's Formula:
The predicted range is 27 to 31. The measured is 30. This falls within the predicted range, so compensation is appropriate. This is a simple metabolic acidosis with appropriate respiratory compensation.
If the measured were 40 (higher than expected), the patient is not ventilating enough. This means a concurrent respiratory acidosis is also present.
If the measured were 20 (lower than expected), the patient is ventilating too much. This means a concurrent respiratory alkalosis is also present.
Worked Example
A
pH
7.25
40
16
Interpretation
Metabolic acidosis, uncompensated (the has not dropped yet)
B
pH
7.30
30
14
Interpretation
Metabolic acidosis, partially compensated (the lungs are blowing off , but pH is still abnormal)
C
pH
7.37
28
16
Interpretation
Metabolic acidosis, fully compensated (pH is back in normal range, sitting on the acidotic side of 7.40)
D
pH
7.52
48
38
Interpretation
Metabolic alkalosis, partially compensated ( is rising but pH remains elevated)
Scenario | pH | Interpretation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
A | 7.25 | 40 | 16 | Metabolic acidosis, uncompensated (the has not dropped yet) |
B | 7.30 | 30 | 14 | Metabolic acidosis, partially compensated (the lungs are blowing off , but pH is still abnormal) |
C | 7.37 | 28 | 16 | Metabolic acidosis, fully compensated (pH is back in normal range, sitting on the acidotic side of 7.40) |
D | 7.52 | 48 | 38 | Metabolic alkalosis, partially compensated ( is rising but pH remains elevated) |
04Anion Gap
When you identify a metabolic acidosis, the very next step is always to calculate the anion gap. This is not optional. Every exam question expects you to do this.
Normal anion gap: 12 mEq/L (some references use 8 to 12 depending on whether albumin-corrected).
Correcting for Albumin
Because albumin is an unmeasured anion, hypoalbuminemia falsely lowers the anion gap. For every 1 g/dL decrease in albumin below 4.0, add 2.5 to the calculated AG.
This correction is tested and is clinically relevant in ICU patients, cirrhotics, and nephrotic syndrome patients.
High Anion Gap Metabolic Acidosis (HAGMA)
The classic mnemonic is MUDPILES (though variants like GOLDMARK exist):
M
Cause
Methanol
Key Feature
Osmolar gap elevated, visual disturbances, formate toxicity
U
Cause
Uremia (renal failure)
Key Feature
Elevated BUN/creatinine, chronic kidney disease
D
Cause
Diabetic ketoacidosis
Key Feature
Hyperglycemia, ketonuria/ketonemia, fruity breath
P
Cause
Propylene glycol / Paraldehyde
Key Feature
Iatrogenic (IV lorazepam drips), osmolar gap
I
Cause
Isoniazid / Iron toxicity
Key Feature
Seizures (isoniazid); GI hemorrhage then shock (iron)
L
Cause
Lactic acidosis
Key Feature
Tissue hypoperfusion, sepsis, shock, seizures, metformin
E
Cause
Ethylene glycol
Key Feature
Osmolar gap, calcium oxalate crystals in urine, renal failure
S
Cause
Salicylates
Key Feature
Tinnitus, mixed respiratory alkalosis AND HAGMA (very testable)
Letter | Cause | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
M | Methanol | Osmolar gap elevated, visual disturbances, formate toxicity |
U | Uremia (renal failure) | Elevated BUN/creatinine, chronic kidney disease |
D | Diabetic ketoacidosis | Hyperglycemia, ketonuria/ketonemia, fruity breath |
P | Propylene glycol / Paraldehyde | Iatrogenic (IV lorazepam drips), osmolar gap |
I | Isoniazid / Iron toxicity | Seizures (isoniazid); GI hemorrhage then shock (iron) |
L | Lactic acidosis | Tissue hypoperfusion, sepsis, shock, seizures, metformin |
E | Ethylene glycol | Osmolar gap, calcium oxalate crystals in urine, renal failure |
S | Salicylates | Tinnitus, mixed respiratory alkalosis AND HAGMA (very testable) |
Normal Anion Gap Metabolic Acidosis (NAGMA)
The mnemonic is HARDUPS:
H
Cause
Hyperalimentation (TPN)
Key Feature
Amino acid metabolism generates
A
Cause
Acetazolamide / Addison disease
Key Feature
Carbonic anhydrase inhibitors cause bicarb wasting
R
Cause
Renal tubular acidosis (RTA)
Key Feature
Types 1, 2, and 4 (see below)
D
Cause
Diarrhea
Key Feature
Loss of -rich intestinal fluid; most common cause
U
Cause
Ureteral diversions
Key Feature
Sigmoid or ileal conduits reabsorb and secrete
P
Cause
Pancreatic fistula
Key Feature
Loss of -rich pancreatic secretions
S
Cause
Saline infusion (large volume)
Key Feature
Dilutional/hyperchloremic acidosis from
Letter | Cause | Key Feature |
|---|---|---|
H | Hyperalimentation (TPN) | Amino acid metabolism generates |
A | Acetazolamide / Addison disease | Carbonic anhydrase inhibitors cause bicarb wasting |
R | Renal tubular acidosis (RTA) | Types 1, 2, and 4 (see below) |
D | Diarrhea | Loss of -rich intestinal fluid; most common cause |
U | Ureteral diversions | Sigmoid or ileal conduits reabsorb and secrete |
P | Pancreatic fistula | Loss of -rich pancreatic secretions |
S | Saline infusion (large volume) | Dilutional/hyperchloremic acidosis from |
A distinguishing feature of NAGMA is that it is always hyperchloremic. As is lost, rises to maintain electroneutrality, so the anion gap stays normal.
The Delta-Delta Ratio
Once you find an elevated anion gap, you must check whether the rise in the anion gap is proportional to the fall in bicarbonate. This is the delta-delta calculation.
Ratio | Interpretation |
|---|---|
< 1 | The has fallen more than the AG has risen. There is a concurrent non-anion gap metabolic acidosis hiding alongside the HAGMA. |
1 to 2 | Pure anion gap metabolic acidosis. The changes are proportional. |
> 2 | The AG has risen more than the has fallen. There is a concurrent metabolic alkalosis that is keeping the artificially high. |
This is the exam writer's favorite tool for testing advanced acid-base reasoning. A patient with DKA who is also vomiting will have a HAGMA with a delta-delta > 2, because the vomiting is generating a concurrent metabolic alkalosis that prevents the bicarbonate from dropping as much as expected.
The single most tested differentiator: Type 4 is the only RTA with hyperkalemia. If you see NAGMA plus hyperkalemia in a diabetic patient, the answer is Type 4 RTA.
05Diagnostic Workup
Arterial Blood Gas (ABG)
Purpose
Determine pH, ,
When to Order
First test in any suspected acid-base disorder
Basic Metabolic Panel (BMP)
Purpose
Obtain , , , , BUN, creatinine, glucose
When to Order
Simultaneously with ABG
Anion Gap Calculation
Purpose
Classify metabolic acidosis
When to Order
Whenever metabolic acidosis is identified
Serum Albumin
Purpose
Correct anion gap for hypoalbuminemia
When to Order
Always in ICU, cirrhosis, nephrotic syndrome
Serum Lactate
Purpose
Identify lactic acidosis
When to Order
Sepsis, shock, altered mental status
Serum Ketones
Purpose
Identify ketoacidosis
When to Order
DKA, alcoholic ketoacidosis, starvation
Osmolar Gap
Purpose
Screen for toxic alcohols
When to Order
Suspected methanol or ethylene glycol ingestion
Urine Anion Gap
Purpose
Differentiate renal vs. extra-renal cause of NAGMA
When to Order
Normal anion gap metabolic acidosis of unclear etiology
Urine pH
Purpose
Classify RTA
When to Order
Suspected renal tubular acidosis
Test | Purpose | When to Order |
|---|---|---|
Arterial Blood Gas (ABG) | Determine pH, , | First test in any suspected acid-base disorder |
Basic Metabolic Panel (BMP) | Obtain , , , , BUN, creatinine, glucose | Simultaneously with ABG |
Anion Gap Calculation | Classify metabolic acidosis | Whenever metabolic acidosis is identified |
Serum Albumin | Correct anion gap for hypoalbuminemia | Always in ICU, cirrhosis, nephrotic syndrome |
Serum Lactate | Identify lactic acidosis | Sepsis, shock, altered mental status |
Serum Ketones | Identify ketoacidosis | DKA, alcoholic ketoacidosis, starvation |
Osmolar Gap | Screen for toxic alcohols | Suspected methanol or ethylene glycol ingestion |
Urine Anion Gap | Differentiate renal vs. extra-renal cause of NAGMA | Normal anion gap metabolic acidosis of unclear etiology |
Urine pH | Classify RTA | Suspected renal tubular acidosis |
The Urine Anion Gap (A Critical Exam Tool)
This is used in NAGMA to determine whether the kidneys are appropriately excreting acid (as ).
Result | Interpretation |
|---|---|
Negative (e.g., -20) | Kidneys are working properly; extra-renal cause (diarrhea is the classic example). The is high because is being excreted. |
Positive (e.g., +15) | Kidneys cannot excrete acid appropriately; renal cause (RTA). |
The mnemonic: "Negative is Normal" for GI losses. If the urine anion gap is negative in NAGMA, think diarrhea. If positive, think RTA.
The Osmolar Gap
An osmolar gap > 10 is abnormal and suggests the presence of unmeasured osmoles, most commonly toxic alcohols (methanol, ethylene glycol, isopropanol) or propylene glycol. This is a screening test, not a confirmatory test.
06Management and Treatment
Metabolic Acidosis (HAGMA)
First-Line Treatment
Treat the underlying cause
Key Details
DKA: insulin + IV fluids + potassium; Toxic alcohols: fomepizole + dialysis; Lactic acidosis: restore perfusion
Metabolic Acidosis (severe, pH < 7.1)
First-Line Treatment
IV sodium bicarbonate
Key Details
Only when pH is dangerously low; goal is to raise pH above 7.1 to 7.2, not to normalize it
Metabolic Alkalosis (saline-responsive)
First-Line Treatment
IV normal saline ()
Key Details
Replenish volume and chloride; this is the treatment for vomiting-induced or diuretic-induced alkalosis
Metabolic Alkalosis (saline-resistant)
First-Line Treatment
Treat the underlying hyperaldosteronism
Key Details
Spironolactone for primary hyperaldosteronism; surgery for Conn syndrome or Cushing syndrome
Respiratory Acidosis (acute)
First-Line Treatment
Improve ventilation
Key Details
Non-invasive positive pressure ventilation (BiPAP) or intubation; naloxone if opioid-induced
Respiratory Acidosis (chronic)
First-Line Treatment
Treat underlying lung disease
Key Details
Bronchodilators, steroids for COPD; avoid excessive oxygen in chronic retainers
Respiratory Alkalosis
First-Line Treatment
Treat the underlying cause
Key Details
Anxiolysis for panic attacks; treat PE, sepsis, or pain as appropriate
Disorder | First-Line Treatment | Key Details |
|---|---|---|
Metabolic Acidosis (HAGMA) | Treat the underlying cause | DKA: insulin + IV fluids + potassium; Toxic alcohols: fomepizole + dialysis; Lactic acidosis: restore perfusion |
Metabolic Acidosis (severe, pH < 7.1) | IV sodium bicarbonate | Only when pH is dangerously low; goal is to raise pH above 7.1 to 7.2, not to normalize it |
Metabolic Alkalosis (saline-responsive) | IV normal saline () | Replenish volume and chloride; this is the treatment for vomiting-induced or diuretic-induced alkalosis |
Metabolic Alkalosis (saline-resistant) | Treat the underlying hyperaldosteronism | Spironolactone for primary hyperaldosteronism; surgery for Conn syndrome or Cushing syndrome |
Respiratory Acidosis (acute) | Improve ventilation | Non-invasive positive pressure ventilation (BiPAP) or intubation; naloxone if opioid-induced |
Respiratory Acidosis (chronic) | Treat underlying lung disease | Bronchodilators, steroids for COPD; avoid excessive oxygen in chronic retainers |
Respiratory Alkalosis | Treat the underlying cause | Anxiolysis for panic attacks; treat PE, sepsis, or pain as appropriate |
Metabolic Acidosis Management
For DKA, the management sequence is: (1) aggressive IV fluid resuscitation with normal saline, (2) potassium replacement if mEq/L before starting insulin (because insulin drives intracellularly and can cause fatal hypokalemia), (3) IV insulin drip at 0.1 units/kg/hour, (4) monitor glucose hourly and switch to dextrose-containing fluids when glucose reaches approximately 200 to 250 mg/dL to prevent hypoglycemia while continuing insulin to clear ketones. The anion gap, not the glucose, determines when to stop the insulin drip.
For toxic alcohol ingestion (methanol, ethylene glycol), the treatment is fomepizole (inhibits alcohol dehydrogenase, blocking conversion to toxic metabolites) plus hemodialysis for severe cases (, renal failure, visual symptoms with methanol, or very high levels). Ethanol infusion is an alternative if fomepizole is unavailable.
Bicarbonate therapy is controversial and reserved for severe acidosis. The generally accepted indications include pH below 7.1, severe hyperkalemia with ECG changes, or certain toxic ingestions. The dose is typically 1 to 2 mEq/kg IV. Risks of bicarbonate include volume overload, overshoot alkalosis, hypokalemia (as shifts intracellularly and follows), and paradoxical CNS acidosis (because crosses the blood-brain barrier more readily than bicarbonate).
Metabolic Alkalosis Management
The most important classification is saline-responsive vs. saline-resistant, determined by urine chloride.
Saline-responsive
Urine
< 20 mEq/L
Causes
Vomiting, NG suction, diuretic use (past), post-hypercapnia
Treatment
IV normal saline, KCl replacement
Saline-resistant
Urine
> 20 mEq/L
Causes
Primary hyperaldosteronism, Cushing syndrome, Bartter/Gitelman syndrome, current diuretic use
Treatment
Treat underlying cause, spironolactone, amiloride
Category | Urine | Causes | Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
Saline-responsive | < 20 mEq/L | Vomiting, NG suction, diuretic use (past), post-hypercapnia | IV normal saline, KCl replacement |
Saline-resistant | > 20 mEq/L | Primary hyperaldosteronism, Cushing syndrome, Bartter/Gitelman syndrome, current diuretic use | Treat underlying cause, spironolactone, amiloride |
In vomiting-induced metabolic alkalosis, the mechanism is loss of from the stomach. The kidneys initially try to excrete the excess bicarbonate, but because of concurrent volume depletion and chloride depletion, the kidneys paradoxically reabsorb bicarbonate (contraction alkalosis). This is why saline works: it replenishes volume and chloride, allowing the kidneys to finally excrete the excess bicarbonate.
Key Management Point for Respiratory Acidosis
In chronic retainers (e.g., severe COPD), the hypoxic drive becomes the primary stimulus for breathing because the central chemoreceptors have adapted to chronic hypercapnia. Giving high-flow oxygen can suppress this drive and worsen hypoventilation. The target oxygen saturation in these patients is 88 to 92%, not 95 to 100%.
07Differential Diagnosis and Distractors
DKA vs. Alcoholic Ketoacidosis (AKA)
Why It Is Similar
Both are HAGMA with ketones
Key Discriminator
DKA: hyperglycemia, high glucose. AKA: low or normal glucose, history of binge drinking followed by poor oral intake
DKA vs. Starvation Ketosis
Why It Is Similar
Both produce ketones
Key Discriminator
Starvation ketosis is mild; rarely drops below 18, and pH is usually normal
Metabolic Acidosis vs. Respiratory Acidosis
Why It Is Similar
Both cause low pH
Key Discriminator
Look at the primary driver: low (metabolic) vs. high (respiratory). Breathing pattern is the clinical clue: Kussmaul = metabolic; hypoventilation = respiratory
Metabolic Alkalosis (vomiting) vs. Respiratory Alkalosis (anxiety)
Why It Is Similar
Both cause high pH
Key Discriminator
Vomiting: is high, may be mildly elevated (compensatory). Anxiety: is low, is normal or slightly low
Salicylate Toxicity vs. Simple HAGMA
Why It Is Similar
Salicylates cause HAGMA
Key Discriminator
Salicylates produce a mixed pattern: early respiratory alkalosis (direct medullary stimulation) PLUS later HAGMA. This combination is the exam fingerprint. Tinnitus is the buzzword.
Type 1 RTA vs. Type 4 RTA
Why It Is Similar
Both are NAGMA
Key Discriminator
Potassium is the differentiator. Type 1: hypokalemia + urine pH > 5.5. Type 4: hyperkalemia + urine pH < 5.5
Diarrhea vs. RTA
Why It Is Similar
Both cause NAGMA
Key Discriminator
Use the urine anion gap. Diarrhea: negative UAG. RTA: positive UAG.
Contraction alkalosis vs. Primary hyperaldosteronism
Why It Is Similar
Both cause metabolic alkalosis with hypokalemia
Key Discriminator
Urine separates them. Contraction: (saline-responsive). Hyperaldosteronism: (saline-resistant), with hypertension
Differential | Why It Is Similar | Key Discriminator |
|---|---|---|
DKA vs. Alcoholic Ketoacidosis (AKA) | Both are HAGMA with ketones | DKA: hyperglycemia, high glucose. AKA: low or normal glucose, history of binge drinking followed by poor oral intake |
DKA vs. Starvation Ketosis | Both produce ketones | Starvation ketosis is mild; rarely drops below 18, and pH is usually normal |
Metabolic Acidosis vs. Respiratory Acidosis | Both cause low pH | Look at the primary driver: low (metabolic) vs. high (respiratory). Breathing pattern is the clinical clue: Kussmaul = metabolic; hypoventilation = respiratory |
Metabolic Alkalosis (vomiting) vs. Respiratory Alkalosis (anxiety) | Both cause high pH | Vomiting: is high, may be mildly elevated (compensatory). Anxiety: is low, is normal or slightly low |
Salicylate Toxicity vs. Simple HAGMA | Salicylates cause HAGMA | Salicylates produce a mixed pattern: early respiratory alkalosis (direct medullary stimulation) PLUS later HAGMA. This combination is the exam fingerprint. Tinnitus is the buzzword. |
Type 1 RTA vs. Type 4 RTA | Both are NAGMA | Potassium is the differentiator. Type 1: hypokalemia + urine pH > 5.5. Type 4: hyperkalemia + urine pH < 5.5 |
Diarrhea vs. RTA | Both cause NAGMA | Use the urine anion gap. Diarrhea: negative UAG. RTA: positive UAG. |
Contraction alkalosis vs. Primary hyperaldosteronism | Both cause metabolic alkalosis with hypokalemia | Urine separates them. Contraction: (saline-responsive). Hyperaldosteronism: (saline-resistant), with hypertension |
08Mixed Acid-Base Disorders
Mixed disorders are tested at the highest level. These occur when two or more primary disorders coexist simultaneously. Some classic combinations you must recognize:
Salicylate toxicity
Expected Disorders
Respiratory alkalosis + HAGMA
How You Detect It
Low beyond what compensation predicts; elevated anion gap
COPD patient with vomiting
Expected Disorders
Respiratory acidosis + metabolic alkalosis
How You Detect It
pH may be near normal; is high AND is very high (higher than expected for compensation alone)
DKA patient with vomiting
Expected Disorders
HAGMA + metabolic alkalosis
How You Detect It
Delta-delta ratio > 2; the is higher than expected for the degree of anion gap elevation
Septic shock
Expected Disorders
Respiratory alkalosis + lactic (HAGMA) acidosis
How You Detect It
Early sepsis drives hyperventilation (low ) while poor tissue perfusion generates lactate
Cardiac arrest / respiratory failure + renal failure
Expected Disorders
Respiratory acidosis + metabolic acidosis
How You Detect It
Both and are moving in opposite directions (high , low bicarb); pH is profoundly low
Clinical Scenario | Expected Disorders | How You Detect It |
|---|---|---|
Salicylate toxicity | Respiratory alkalosis + HAGMA | Low beyond what compensation predicts; elevated anion gap |
COPD patient with vomiting | Respiratory acidosis + metabolic alkalosis | pH may be near normal; is high AND is very high (higher than expected for compensation alone) |
DKA patient with vomiting | HAGMA + metabolic alkalosis | Delta-delta ratio > 2; the is higher than expected for the degree of anion gap elevation |
Septic shock | Respiratory alkalosis + lactic (HAGMA) acidosis | Early sepsis drives hyperventilation (low ) while poor tissue perfusion generates lactate |
Cardiac arrest / respiratory failure + renal failure | Respiratory acidosis + metabolic acidosis | Both and are moving in opposite directions (high , low bicarb); pH is profoundly low |
The clue to a mixed disorder is that the compensation does not match what the formulas predict. When the measured compensatory value is outside the expected range, a second primary process is present.
09Traps and High-Yield Pearls
The single most common way students fail acid-base questions is by stopping after identifying the primary disorder without checking compensation. The exam deliberately gives you ABGs where the numbers look like a simple disorder, but the compensation is off, hiding a second process. Always calculate.
Trap 1: Normal pH does not mean normal. A pH of 7.40 with a of 60 and of 36 is not a "normal ABG." It is a fully compensated respiratory acidosis. If you see normal pH with abnormal and , that is pathology.
Trap 2: Forgetting to calculate the anion gap. Every time you identify metabolic acidosis, the anion gap calculation is mandatory. Skipping this step means you miss the etiology.
Trap 3: Forgetting the delta-delta. You found an elevated anion gap. Great. But is the bicarbonate dropping proportionally? If not, there is a hidden metabolic alkalosis or an additional NAGMA. This is the highest-yield calculation for advanced questions.
Trap 4: Confusing acute and chronic compensation in respiratory disorders. A patient with chronic COPD will have a much higher compensatory than an acute asthma attack patient with the same . Using the acute formula for a chronic patient will make you falsely diagnose a concurrent metabolic alkalosis.
Trap 5: Salicylate toxicity. This is the classic mixed disorder on exams. Students see the HAGMA and stop. They miss the concurrent respiratory alkalosis, which is the early and dominant feature. If a vignette mentions tinnitus, altered mental status, and an ABG showing both low and elevated anion gap, salicylate poisoning is the answer.
Trap 6: Potassium in DKA. The serum potassium is high on presentation despite total body potassium depletion. Never give insulin until you confirm mEq/L (some guidelines use 5.3 as the threshold above which you hold potassium replacement, not insulin). Starting insulin with low potassium causes fatal arrhythmias.
The core competency being tested across all acid-base questions is your ability to systematically interpret ABGs using the 5-step algorithm, apply the compensation formulas to detect hidden disorders, and connect the laboratory findings to a clinical scenario that determines treatment. The exam rewards methodical, stepwise reasoning and punishes pattern-matching shortcuts.